Penn South co-op board evicts Airbnb, Roomorama devotee

Private investigator found tenant had rented out terrace for $65/night

321 Eighth Avenue
321 Eighth Avenue

A resident of Penn South, a 2,820-unit affordable housing co-op at 321 Eighth Avenue in Chelsea, is facing eviction after renting out his terrace to someone later revealed to be a private investigator sent by the co-op board.

Retired typographer David Shea — who found the renter through rental booking website Roomorama and often uses Airbnb — is one of five residents at the co-op subject to eviction proceedings. In 2011 and last year, the 78-year-old hosted roughly 50 people on his 19th-floor terrace and earned about $6,000 over that time. Some travelers hailed from Oklahoma or New Zealand, each paying $65 a night for lodging.

“I told them at the hearing, you didn’t have to hire a private investigator: If you had asked me, I would have admitted it,” Shea told the New York Times.

Sign Up for the undefined Newsletter

By signing up, you agree to TheRealDeal Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy.

Shea has opted to appeal the eviction in New York State Supreme Court in Manhattan.

“David is a great host, and has extensive knowledge of the area,” an Australian reviewer on Airbnb’s website wrote, as cited by the New York Times. “Just don’t be a prissy cleanfreak and you’ll be fine.”

In September, Airbnb won a big victory in court after a case against an East Village resident, who was originally given a $40,000 fine for renting out his apartment using the site, was overturned, as previously reported. [NYT]Mark Maurer