AXA tower: a good comp at $611 per sf?

TRD New York /
Jun.June 25, 2009 04:16 PM

With few comparable building sales to price Midtown trophy properties, an appraisal of the 1.8 million-square-foot 787 Seventh Avenue at $611 per square foot provides the market with one more data point.

Or does it?

AXA Equitable Life Insurance filed a deed with the city June 17 valuing the 51-story office tower it owns on Seventh Avenue between 51st and 52nd streets at $1.1 billion, or about $611 per square foot, property records posted yesterday show.

A spokesperson for AXA Equitable said the company contracted an appraisal of the fully leased office tower within the second quarter of 2009 by an unidentified third-party firm, but would not comment further.

The deed did not represent a sale, but only a transfer from one AXA Equitable entity to another, the city records show.

Experts said the valuation of $611 per foot seemed a little high because nothing has sold in that price range recently. 1540 Broadway sold for about $392 per foot in March, and Worldwide Plaza at 825 Eighth Avenue was in contract reportedly in the mid-$300s per square foot. American International Group sold 70 Pine Street for about $100 per square foot.

And this deed transfer was not viewed as a real “comp” anyway because it was not a sale, said John Cicero, managing principal at commercial appraisal firm Miller Cicero.

“Real data points are from closed transactions. The AIG sale, and Worldwide Plaza, which was almost a sale — those are the real data points you want to look to,” he said.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Long Island Cheat Sheet: Deadline again extended for Nassau Coliseum proposals … & more

Long Island Cheat Sheet: Deadline again extended for Nassau Coliseum proposals … & more

Fairstead lands $85M loan for Harlem housing complex

Fairstead lands $85M loan for Harlem housing complex

Thor Equities scores $85M for Midtown HQ

Thor Equities scores $85M for Midtown HQ

Goldman to take lead on $1.2B refi of One Worldwide Plaza

Goldman to take lead on $1.2B refi of
One Worldwide Plaza

Did lack of foreign interest doom NYRT’s sale of One Worldwide Plaza?

Did lack of foreign interest doom NYRT’s sale of One Worldwide Plaza?

SL Green, RXR partnership in lead to buy One Worldwide Plaza for $1.7B

SL Green, RXR partnership in lead to buy One Worldwide Plaza for $1.7B

The $100 billion interview: Blackstone’s top US real estate exec on the one that got away

The $100 billion interview: Blackstone’s top US real estate exec on the one that got away

Blumenfeld gets $77M loan for 125th Street project 

Blumenfeld gets $77M loan for 125th Street project 

arrow_forward_ios