Court gives hope to Manhattan House tenants

New York /
Aug.August 13, 2009 07:17 PM
alternate textManhattan House and attorney Adam Leitman Bailey (Left photo source: PropertyShark.com)

A group of 24 market-rate tenants at the struggling Upper East Side condominium Manhattan House were granted the right to appeal their evictions to the New York State Appellate Division, a move that could renew the debate over the rights of non-stabilized tenants in a residential conversion.

In December 2008, an appeals court overturned an earlier ruling to block the evictions of 29 tenants at Manhattan House, who were originally issued eviction notices during the conversion of the property from a rental building to a condo.

The tenants refused to leave the building after developers Peter Kalikow and Jeremiah O’Connor acquired the building at 200 East 66th Street, for a record $623 million in 2005. The developers planned to convert the 583-unit rental building into a luxury condo, but faced significant legal opposition from tenants who challenged the legality of their evictions.

Attorney Adam Leitman Bailey, who is handling the tenants’ appeal, says he will argue that the tenants were legal occupants of their apartments at the time of the conversion and had the right to get their leases renewed.

Lawyers for the tenants previously argued that the developer tried to illegally push out market rate tenants from their apartments through harassment, by offering new leases with exorbitant rent hikes and refusing to accept rent payments. The court ruled, however, that the landlord merely exercised his right not to renew tenants with expired leases.

O’Connor, who bought out Kalikow’s stake in Manhattan House in 2007, has since failed to sell hundreds of apartments under a severe economic downturn and a bloated market in which some critics charge that Manhattan House offered overpriced apartments at more than $2,000 a square foot. O’Connor has renovated about 150 apartments in the tower, but closed less than 90 sales, as dozens of buyers either failed to obtain financing or refused to close. Another 200 units are occupied by rent-stabilized tenants, and the remaining units are unsold.

Four of the original 29 market-rate tenants have since entered agreements to buy their apartments, and a fifth tenant previously occupied the apartment under an extended lease, rendering their cases null and void, according to legal documents obtained by The Real Deal.

Officials at O’Connor’s company O’Connor Capital declined to comment.

In July, a similar group of market-rate tenants at Sheffield57 appealed their case to the Appellate Division, but the New York State Attorney General negotiated an agreement with that building’s former developer Kent Swig, which would give market-rate tenants “use and occupancy agreements,” which are similar to leases.

Under that negotiated agreement, market-rate tenants at Sheffield57 agreed to an average 6 percent increase in rent.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Miles Kwok with 781 Fifth Avenue (
Trustee alleges “shell game” over Chinese exile’s UES penthouse
Trustee alleges “shell game” over Chinese exile’s UES penthouse
A photo illustration of Adam Leitman Bailey (far left) and Miki Naftali (right) (Getty Images, Naftali Group, Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C.)
Naftali tenant suffers blow in holdout battle
Naftali tenant suffers blow in holdout battle
From left: Adam Leitman Bailey P.C.'s Steven Wagner; Belkin Burden Goldman's Sherwin Belkin; Adam Leitman Bailey P.C.'s Adam Leitman Bailey; and Naftali Group’s Miki Naftali (Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal with Getty Images, Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C., Belkin Burden Goldman)
Pay up or lawyer up: What does a holdout cost a developer?
Pay up or lawyer up: What does a holdout cost a developer?
Adam Leitman Bailey, Y. David Scharf, and Miki Naftali with 215 West 84th Street (Adam Leitman Bailey, Morrison Cohen, Getty)
Naftali lays out project as holdout tenant plays new card
Naftali lays out project as holdout tenant plays new card
 Miki Naftali and Adam Leitman Bailey (Getty, Adam Leitman Bailey; Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
Heavyweight lawyers at war in Naftali holdout drama
Heavyweight lawyers at war in Naftali holdout drama
Steven Wagner, Bonnie Reid Berkow and Adam Leitman Bailey (Wagner, Berkow & Brandt, Adam Leitman Bailey)
Prominent real estate lawyer leaves firm he started to join Adam Leitman Bailey
Prominent real estate lawyer leaves firm he started to join Adam Leitman Bailey
 Adam Leitman Bailey with 6 Turtle Knoll in Monroe (Adam Leitman Bailey Law Firm, Trulia)
NY foreclosure ban does not apply to shell companies, judge rules
NY foreclosure ban does not apply to shell companies, judge rules
A condo building couldn’t collapse in NYC. Or could it?
A condo building couldn’t collapse in NYC. Or could it?
A condo building couldn’t collapse in NYC. Or could it?
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...