Preservationists meet with backlash from Carroll Gardens’ longtime residents

TRD New York /
Dec.December 09, 2009 08:52 AM

In Carroll Gardens, preservationists seeking landmark status for a greater portion of the neighborhood are being met with opposition from residents and merchants who want to retain the right to determine their properties’ appearances. Guidelines stipulated by the neighborhood’s current two-block historic district are also expensive, they say. The Landmarks Preservation Commission requires that designs of windows, staircases and front gates in the historic district evoke a late 19th century feel, and opponents say some property owners — especially the area’s elderly Italian immigrant population — won’t be able to front the cost of replacements if the district is expanded. Still, those who are in favor of landmarking say it is a necessary step for Carroll Gardens, which is already mired in a battle about overdevelopment. The city changed its zoning rules in October to limit the size of new buildings to five stories in most of the neighborhood, and preservationists say those changes alone won’t be enough to protect the character of a district that originally became popular for its brownstones. [NYDN]

Related Articles

The Strand Bookstore and store owner Nancy Bass Wyden (Credit: Getty Images)

Over owner’s protests, city landmarks Strand bookstore

Revamped design for 550 Madison receives Landmarks’ approval

The Top 10 preservation fights of 2018

The Strand’s building could become an official landmark despite owner’s opposition

Ditmas Park home at center of dispute between church and late pastor’s family

Meet Prospect Height’s trash hoarder who owns $8M worth of NYC brownstones

550 Madison is now a landmark

Sorry, developers: The Boerum Hill historic district is expanding