Court rejects Atlantic Yards MTA sale suit

TRD New York /
Dec.December 21, 2009 11:56 AM

The State Supreme Court has rejected a lawsuit that alleges the Metropolitan Transportation Authority acted inappropriately in its sale of the Vanderbilt rail yard to Bruce Ratner, developer of the controversial Atlantic Yards site. A collection of community advocacy groups, including Develop Don’t Destroy Brooklyn, alleged in the suit that the MTA inappropriately reopened a deal this year with Ratner that was made in 2005 rather than reappraise the arrangement. Daniel Goldstein, a spokesperson for Develop Don’t Destroy Brooklyn, said that this constituted favoritism on the part of the MTA, referring to the developer and the MTA’s arrangement as a “sweetheart deal.” The court saw things differently, ruling in favor of the MTA. “If every change were to be viewed as a new plan so as to trigger anew each mandated review process, no development plan could ever reach final approval,” the ruling says. “The MTA had a rational basis for continuing to use the 2005 appraisal rather than ordering a new one in 2009.”

Related Articles


Second Ave subway’s next phase could impact Durst, Extell dev sites

Corey Johnson’s MTA reform plan targets controversial Scaffold Law

MTA renews 50K sf at Forest City’s
1 Pierrepont Plaza in Brooklyn

The MTA is still spending millions to maintain its empty headquarters

Inside the dismantling of Forest City Ratner

De Blasio to Cuomo: You’ve got the money, now fix MTA and NYCHA

Cuomo made appointments to state boards. Then, in apparent defiance of his own executive order, he cashed their checks

To pay for the broken MTA, Cuomo wants to tax landlords near new subway projects