Concrete tester sues DOB over license

TRD New York /
Jan.January 08, 2010 06:25 PM

The city’s Department of Buildings is facing litigation from concrete testing company Big Apple Testing, a Queens-based firm whose license renewal was denied last September amid a citywide crackdown on concrete testing standards.

Big Apple Testing filed a so-called Article 78 suit against the buildings department Monday, asking the court for an injunction that would reinstate its concrete testing license or compel the agency to hold a hearing on the case.

Stuart Klein, attorney for Big Apple Testing, said no legitimate reason was given for the license denial, and speculated that the buildings department is looking to secretly weed out certain firms to cover for a widening scandal about construction defects.

“They’re being cute,” Klein said. “They look for guys that are coming up for renewal and say, ‘we won’t renew your license.’ There appears to be no presentation of evidence and you’re effectively boxing against shadows.”

Court filings show that Big Apple had been licensed to test concrete for more than 18 years, involving thousands of sites per year. The firm has annual revenue of more than $900,000. Klein did not have specific details about previous projects the firm worked on.

A formal hearing is scheduled for Jan. 20.

Gus Sirakis, deputy director of the DOB Office of Technical Certification and research, originally contacted the firm in November 2008, instructing the firm to cease all concrete testing work, even though the firm had requested the renewal the prior month, court documents show.

Buildings department officials did not respond to a request for comment.

Just two days before Big Apple’s license renewal was denied, the buildings department announced a major program to raise oversight of concrete testing around the city.

On Sept. 2, the city announced plans to create a new concrete testing lab in the Bronx and said it would create a new concrete testing unit at the agency, part of an overall plan to retest 82 buildings and construction sites around the city.

The city plan followed the indictment of another concrete testing company, Testwell Laboratories, for allegedly falsifying concrete testing documents at sites across the city. In December, Testwell, along with four of its top executives, went on trial for allegedly falsifying concrete safety reports at more than 100 projects around the city, including the new Yankee Stadium and the Freedom Tower site at the former World Trade Center.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
(iStock, NYC.gov)

NYC buildings are getting energy efficiency grades

NYC buildings are getting energy efficiency grades
Melanie La Rocca (iStock)

City moves to speed opening of new and renovated properties

City moves to speed opening of new and renovated properties
348 Court Street (Photo by Justin Heiman/Getty Images)

Collapses raise questions about safety-law exemption

Collapses raise questions about safety-law exemption
136 East 36 Street and 211 East 34th Street (CitizenApp)

Midtown scaffolding collapse kills one, hours after building crumbles nearby

Midtown scaffolding collapse kills one, hours after building crumbles nearby
1323 Boston Road, Jeff Fox (Credit: Google Maps)

Foxy Management plans another Bronx senior housing project

Foxy Management plans another Bronx senior housing project
An aerial of 700 Atlantic Avenue with Greenland USA CEO Hu Gang (Credit: Google Maps; Gang via CGCC)

Greenland plans 41-story resi tower at Pacific Park

Greenland plans 41-story resi tower at Pacific Park
DOB Commissioner Melanie E. La Rocca (Credit: iStock)

City tweaks affordable housing construction rules to comply with state guidelines

City tweaks affordable housing construction rules to comply with state guidelines
Governor Andrew Cuomo (Credit: Cuomo by  (Photos by John Lamparski/NurPhoto; Newsday RM via Getty Images)

State allows more construction, but raises questions on housing

State allows more construction, but raises questions on housing
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...