Extell wins judgment in broker commission case at the Lucida

TRD New York /
Mar.March 04, 2010 01:07 PM
The Lucida at 151 East 85th Street, Gary Barnett

A State Supreme Court judge ruled against residential broker Sloane Square NYC after the firm’s clients failed to close on two apartments at the Lucida condominium on the Upper East Side and the developer demanded a refund of the commission.

New York State Supreme Court Judge James Yates awarded a judgment in favor of Extell Development, which advanced half of the 3 percent commission payments up front and then demanded the money back after the buyers failed to close.

“Defendant was to receive a 3 percent commission for certain qualifying sales and defendant expressly acknowledged and agreed that it shall not be deemed to have earned a brokerage commission unless title closes and the agreed upon purchase price is paid or the prescribed consideration is delivered to or accepted by sponsor at closing,” Yates wrote in his Feb. 23 decision.

Extell President Gary Barnett said the decision was fair and reasonable given that the contract called for commissions to be paid for a completed sale.

“It kind of speaks for itself,” he told The Real Deal.

The Lucida, at 151 East 85th Street, is one of the highest profile condominium projects in Manhattan, competing against the Brompton, a high-profile condominium project from Related. About half of the units at the Lucida have closed and more than 80 percent are under contract, Barnett said. 

The purchasers signed two separate agreements with Extell in May 2007 to buy unit 16J for $5.88 million and apartment 12A for $7.17 million. Extell paid the Sloane Square broker, who was not identified in the suit, two 1.5 percent advances, or about $195,745, when the contracts were signed and agreed to pay the remaining balance when the deal closed.

The buyers refused to close on their apartments, however, and the developer sent notices to the broker in June 2009 demanding a refund of the commission advances, according to court filings. The broker refused, arguing the firm was entitled to keep the advance commissions, which lawyers said modified the terms of the original agreements. The broker also argued that the original agreement was more than one year old and could not be enforced. 

Jaar-mel Sloane, head of Sloane Square, and Katherine Harrison, the company’s attorney, declined to comment on the case.

Related Articles

One Manhattan Square Extell Development CEO Gary Barnett (Credit: Curbed NY)

Extell lands $690M refinancing package for One Manhattan Square

Related's Jamar Adams and Steve Ross with 14-06 Gateway Boulevard (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

Related is the latest developer to target the Rockaways

Extell Development's Gary Barnett (Credit: Getty Images and iStock)

Chelsea residents paid Gary Barnett $11M to protect their views from a planned tower

Jay Kriegel (Credit: Kent Presents)

Jay Kriegel, Related senior adviser and ex-mayoral chief of staff, dies

Brooklyn Point at 138 Willoughby Street and Extell Development’s Gary Barnett (Credit: Alistair Gardiner for The Real Deal)

And you get an incentive! Extell offers to pay carrying costs at Brooklyn’s tallest tower

55 Hudson Yards, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg (Credit: Google Maps and Getty Images)

Here’s how much Facebook is paying at Hudson Yards

Huizenga lobbied Rick Scott to secure Opportunity Zone designation for West Palm site

Huizenga lobbied Rick Scott to secure Opportunity Zone designation for West Palm site

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg and Hudson Yards (Credit: Getty Images)

It’s official: Facebook is taking 1.5M sf in Hudson Yards