New lawsuit charges JPMorgan with denying home loan modifications

TRD New York /
May.May 04, 2010 08:58 AM

Queens homeowner Alex Lam was up-to-date on his mortgage payments until recently, when he tried to apply for a loan modification under HAMP, the federal Home Affordable Modification Program.

When Lam contacted his loan servicer, Washington Mutual, to ask how to take advantage of the federal program, he was told that he’d only be eligible for a loan modification if he temporarily stopped making his payments.

So that’s what he did. But he was not offered the permanent modification he’d been hoping for. Instead, his home was foreclosed on, though the lender said that wouldn’t occur, said Ted De Barbieri, a staff attorney at the non-profit Urban Justice Center, which is filing a lawsuit today against the lender on behalf of Lam and two other Queens homeowners.

“Listening to the advice of his lender, he stopped making payments and went into default,” De Barbieri said. “In addition to the deceit around telling him to stop making payments, they told him the home would not be foreclosed on.”

The Manhattan-based Urban Justice Center filed the lawsuit in Eastern District Federal Court against JPMorgan Chase (which recently acquired Washington Mutual) for “illegally delaying and denying” the loan modifications of the three homeowners, the group said.

The organization is holding a press conference today at noon to announce the suit.

“We think that these homeowners have been systematically denied home loan modifications under the HAMP program,” De Barbieri said.

HAMP has been widely criticized for failing to effectively stem the tide of foreclosures.

Under HAMP rules, homeowners who make three months of trial payments should automatically be granted a permanent modification.

Lam and the two other homeowners named in the suit, Shanaz Begum and Tamara Williams, made their trial payments but were not granted new mortgage terms, according to the Urban Justice Center, which has been working with Chase since last year to modify the three homeowners’ loans, De Barbieri said.

Lam, Begum and Williams were not available for comment by press time, but will be present at the news conference, the Urban Justice Center said.

“The fact is that the individuals we’ve been working with have not been receiving the type of upfront negotiations with the lender that they’re supposed to,” De Barbieri said. “No one is enforcing this.”

The problem is not limited to these three homeowners, added Carmella Huang, a staff attorney at the Urban Justice Center. Like Lam, other homeowners have been told to stop making their payments, which often leads to bad credit and foreclosure, but rarely the loan modifications they hope for.

“We’ve heard from others that the same advice is being doled out around the country,” Huang said.

Because interest rates automatically spike once a borrower is in default, loan servicers “have an incentive to delay the process,” she said, adding: “The few people who have gotten permanent loan modifications are like rare diamonds.”
JP Morgan Chase declined to comment.

In the first quarter of 2010, the company reported that it had offered 750,000 loans modifications since the beginning of 2009. The company services some 10.3 million mortgages.

Related Articles

A rendering of 165 Broome Street (Credit: Handel Architects)

Nonprofit plans affordable housing development near Essex Crossing

All Falls Down: Kanye West’s “Star Wars”-themed affordable housing plan hits snag

All Falls Down: Kanye West’s “Star Wars”-themed affordable housing plan hits snag

 NYCHA CEO Gregory Russ and NYCHA houses (Credit: Minneapolis Public Housing Authority and Getty Images)

NYCHA head: Agency now needs $40B in repairs

Carl Heastie highlighted homelessness and housing affordability in remarks to open the 2020 session (Credit: Facebook, Getty Images)

Heastie drills down on homelessness, affordable housing

Clockwise from left: Kings Plaza Shopping Center in Brooklyn, 45-18 Court Square  in Long Island City with GFP's Eric Gural, and 150-13 89th Avenue in Jamaica 

Brooklyn mall’s $487M tops outer-borough loan list

147-07 94th Avenue in Jamaica and Pheonix Realty Group president Keith Rosenthal (Credit: Google Maps)

Phoenix Realty, Artimus snag $181M loan for Jamaica resi project

Creston Apartments at 2030 Creston Avenue in the Bronx (Credit: Google Maps, iStock)

Construction firm with alleged mob ties worked on Bronx affordable housing project

2000 Valentine Avenue and 1985 Webster Avenue (Credit: Google Maps)

Investors partner on $170M Bronx affordable housing purchase