Judge dismisses CRP/Extell case, orders release of Rushmore deposits

New York /
Oct.October 13, 2010 08:15 PM
 
Rushmore

A federal District Court judge dismissed a lawsuit by Carlyle Realty Partners and Extell Development against Attorney General Andrew Cuomo and ordered the release of $16 million in escrow deposits to buyers at the Rushmore condominium.

The combined entity, CRP/Extell, filed suit against Cuomo in May after he allowed 41 buyers to back out of their contracts at the condo, at 80 Riverside Boulevard. CRP/Extell argued that Cuomo deprived them of their 14th amendment rights when he ordered the rescission of the contracts.

Judge George Daniels sided with the AG, who contended that the proper forum for an appeal was a so-called Article 78 lawsuit in New York State Supreme Court, and that federal court had no jurisdiction over the matter.

“Under Article 78, CRP/Extell has the right to Have A State Court determine that the New York AG’s determination ‘was made in violation of lawful procedure, was affected by an error of law or was arbitrary or capricious,” Daniels wrote in the order. “If a material issue of fact is raised, CRP/Extell would be entitled to a full trial of the disputed issues.”

An Extell executive, who asked not to be named, noted that Daniels ordered the escrow agent, Stroock, Stroock & Lavan, to refund the deposits within 30 days, unless a New York State court grants a stay on the release of the funds. The executive would not comment on whether the company plans to Ask The Supreme Court for such a stay.

Within the past month, a federal appeals court denied a request by CRP/Extell to block the release of the funds, leading to a behind-the-scenes effort by the AG to urge Daniels to order the release of the money. Stroock asked the federal court to tell it what to do because CRP/Extell officials instructed it not to release the funds last month based on the assumption there was an automatic stay.

CRP/Extell has claimed all along that the buyers took advantage of a “scrivener’s error” in the offering plan, which stated the buyers must be granted rescission of their purchases if the first unit sale did not close by Sept. 1, 2008. CRP/Extell claimed that the true deadline was Sept. 1, 2009, but lawyers for the buyers have disputed the claim that there was a scrivener’s error and claim that CRP/Extell intentionally set a September 2008 deadline to encourage sales at the condo. Carlyle wasn’t immediately available for comment and nor were Gary Barnett, president of Extell and lawyers for the buyers and Stroock.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Governor Andrew Cuomo and Senator James Skoufis (Credit: Getty Images, NY Senate)
Owners of some residential properties can’t hide behind LLCs anymore
Owners of some residential properties can’t hide behind LLCs anymore
One Manhattan Square Extell Development CEO Gary Barnett (Credit: Curbed NY)
Extell lands $690M refinancing package for One Manhattan Square
Extell lands $690M refinancing package for One Manhattan Square
Governor Andrew Cuomo and 538 Johnson Avenue in Brooklyn (Credit: Google Maps and Getty Images)
Landlords take another hit: Cuomo signs expanded Loft Law
Landlords take another hit: Cuomo signs expanded Loft Law
From left: Vorea Group’s Peter Papamichael, Turnbridge Equities’ Andrew Joblon and Chetrit Group’s Joseph Chetrit
Ranking New York’s most active developers
Ranking New York’s most active developers
Extell's Gary Barnett, Robert Gans and an aerial of 616 11th Avenue (Robert’s Steakhouse, Google Maps)
Investor Robert Gans files for bankruptcy to thwart Barnett, Eli Tabak
Investor Robert Gans files for bankruptcy to thwart Barnett, Eli Tabak
Extell Development's Gary Barnett and 171-179 East 86th Street (Extell Development, iStock)
Checkmate for Papaya King: Extell files demo plans on UES
Checkmate for Papaya King: Extell files demo plans on UES
Gary Barnett along with renderings of 1637 First Avenue (Extell Development, iStock)
Extell lands $125M loan for UES resi project
Extell lands $125M loan for UES resi project
Netflix co-founder Reed Hastings (Getty Images, iStock)
Netflix bids on 289-acre land in New Jersey
Netflix bids on 289-acre land in New Jersey
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...