Discrimination against pregnant women an issue in mortgage industry

TRD New York /
Jun.June 10, 2011 11:44 AM

Should being pregnant and taking maternity leave ever constitute reasons to be turned down for a home mortgage or having your loan closing postponed?

You might think not, but two new legal actions by federal fair lending regulators suggest that the mortgage industry — and even federally run financing giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac — may need to address the issue.

In one case, a Seattle-area physician settled a discrimination complaint with Cornerstone Mortgage Co., a national mortgage banking firm based in Houston. In the second, the Department of Housing and Urban Development accused MGIC, one of the country’s highest-volume mortgage insurers, of discrimination by underwriters against a Pennsylvania homeowner whose application allegedly was denied because she was on maternity leave.

In the Cornerstone settlement, federal regulators alleged that the lender initially approved the applicant for a mortgage but later said that her income while on maternity leave could not be considered in qualifying for the loan. That, in turn, was a violation of the Fair Housing Act, said regulators, because it limited her ability to obtain financing based on her “sex and/or familial status.”

Cornerstone did not respond to a request for comment, but in the settlement agreement denied any wrongdoing and said the issue arose because the applicant “failed to disclose… that she would be on leave from her employment.”
As part of the settlement, Cornerstone agreed to pay the applicant $15,000, and to create a $750,000 escrow fund to pay potential claims from other women who may have been harmed by Cornerstone’s maternity leave policies during the past two years.

The government’s complaint against MGIC alleged that the company denied a Pennsylvania couple’s application for insurance “unless and until the wife returned to work from maternity leave.” An MGIC spokeswoman said the company’s policy is not to comment on pending litigation.

John Trasvina, HUD’s assistant secretary for fair housing and equal opportunity, said federal law on the issue of maternity leave is clear: “Pregnancy is not a basis to deny or delay a loan. Mortgage professionals may verify income and other resources and have eligibility standards, but they may not single out women on maternity leave to deny or delay loans that they are otherwise eligible for.”

Kristin Rowe-Finkbeiner, executive director of MomsRising, a group that advocates for equitable treatment of mothers, said in an interview that the Cornerstone and MGIC cases are emblematic of the widespread but little-publicized discrimination that working mothers face.

“This is very common — it just doesn’t get a lot of attention” from the mortgage industry or, until now, from the government, she said. Her group has received 200 reports of alleged discrimination from credit applicants because they were on — or scheduled to begin — maternity leave.

Much of the problem, said Rowe-Finkbeiner, arises from “outdated assumptions” about working women who get pregnant and need to take leave. “The assumption is that women may not be returning to their jobs,” and therefore counting their income toward loan qualification is risky for the lender. But in fact, today’s economic realities require most of them to resume their employment in order to help support the family and pay the bills, including the mortgage, she said.

Some lenders and loan officers, however, counter that the real problem is that they have not received specific-enough instructions on how to handle maternity leave situations from the giants of the mortgage arena — Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

John Councilman, CEO of AMC Mortgage, said in an interview that he is “surprised” that the two dominant investors have provided no detailed guidance on how to evaluate income from applicants on, or heading for, maternity leave.

Spokespersons for both companies confirmed that maternity and pregnancy are not addressed by name in their manuals for lenders, but this does not mean lenders are free to discriminate against applicants who can demonstrate that they qualify for a mortgage — whether pregnant or on maternity leave.

Amy Bonitatibus, Fannie Mae’s spokesperson, said the company’s rules “do not preclude lenders from underwriting mortgages for borrowers receiving short-term disability payments, on short-term leave or expecting to be on short-term leave, including borrowers on maternity leave.”

HUD said it is currently reviewing both companies’ guidance to lenders “to determine if they satisfy the Fair Housing Act, including income verifications for persons taking maternity or parental leave.”
Bottom line — if you (or a spouse) have experienced discrimination on a mortgage application because you are on maternity leave or plan to be, you may have a remedy: File a complaint with HUD at (800) 669-9777 or on its website in the fair lending area.

Ken Harney is a syndicated real estate columnist.

Related Articles

The Sand Castle apartment complex at 7-11 Seagirt Ave in Far Rockaway (Credit: Google Maps)

Queens landlords settle record $1M discrimination case

Cammeby's International Group founder Rubin Schron and, from top: 194-05 67th Avenue, 189-15 73rd Avenue and 64-05 186th Lane (Credit: Google Maps)

Ruby Schron lands $500M refi for sprawling Queens apartment portfolio

1735 York Avenue and Bonjour Capital's Charles Dayan (Credit: Google Maps)

Dayan’s Bonjour Capital inks $115M refi for Upper East Side building

US home mortgage debt surges past pre-recession record

US home mortgage debt surges past pre-recession record

Secretary of the Department of Housing and Urban Development Ben Carson (Credit: Getty Images and iStock)

“Rich people are going to get richer anyway”: HUD Secretary Ben Carson dismisses concerns that Opportunity Zones will only benefit rich people

448 East 143rd Street in the Bronx (Credit: Google Maps)

Private developer’s NYCHA project in Mott Haven lands $79M in financing

FHFA director Mark Calabria is ready to set Fannie and Freddie free, while Wall Street worries about potential risks.

Wall Street warns against privatizing Fannie and Freddie without Congress guarantee

FHFA director Mark Calabria (Credit: Federal Housing Finance Agency and Getty Images)

Trump official to pressure Congress to privatize Freddie and Fannie