The Real Deal on the town

1212 Fifth Avenue attempts to merge the modern with the old

TRD New York /
Sep.September 21, 2011 03:39 PM

Durst Organization President Douglas Durst, the Fetner family and various brokers, public relations gurus and hangers-on mingled at the grand debut of Durst Fetner Residential’s new 55-unit condominium development at 1212 Fifth Avenue last night, enjoying market chit chat and sensational appetizers (see photos above).

It was a lavish affair; the catering by award-winning chef and cookbook author Marcus Samuelsson of Red Rooster held its own against the pull of the Central Park views, featuring a swan carved from a large melon and various platters of exotic vegetables and dips, as well as cheeses.

Randi Fetner Sherman, a principal and executive vice president of Durst Fetner Residential, gave The Real Deal the grand tour of four separate units on the ninth floor of the building.

The apartments on view, with interiors by Russell Groves, range in price from $745,000 for a one-bedroom to $3.31 million for a three-bedroom. On the West Side of the building, residents will overlook the park.

“The building is precariously close to being [declared] effective,” said Adam Rosenberg, an assistant project manager at Durst Fetner, referring to the property’s certificate of occupancy, adding, “any day now.”


Rosenberg also noted that seven units had closed so far since the condo soft launched in the summer. Four or five more will soon follow, he said. Move-ins are expected to begin in December though some of the penthouse units are not yet complete.
As for the building’s available units overall, there are currently 18 active listings for the building, according to The priciest on offer is a $7.995 million penthouse unit, with 2,689 square feet.

Durst Fetner purchased the building in 2009 from the Mount Sinai Medical Center for an undisclosed amount, though it was said to be just under $100 million, according to reports from the time. As part of the all-cash deal, the company will oversee the development of a 32-story rental apartment tower next door above a mechanical space used as the hospital’s labs.

The prewar 1212 Fifth Avenue has had a complete gut renovation.

“It was difficult to merge [the old building] with the modern, forward-thinking design,” said Groves, pointing to the moldings on the ceiling as an example of his work, but still a throw-back to its original features.

The custom-made finishes were attracting some attention last night. The Real Deal overheard a broker from Gumley Haft Kleier inquiring about the drawer handles. “My kitchen is handle-less,” he said, “because I can’t settle on a handle.”

Related Articles

Douglas Durst and the NYC ferry on the East River (Credit: Curbed NY)

Durst wants to extend East River ferry service to UES

These real estate heavyweights were invited to Cuomo’s secretive fundraiser

NYCHA’s deal with Fetner Properties for market-rate housing still hasn’t closed — two years later

Collection of Durst LLCs donate $160K to attorney general candidates

Law firm Perkins Coie takes 60K sf at Durst’s 1155 Sixth

City officials, construction workers protest Durst’s Queens Plaza Park project

Durst plans temporary cultural center for Hallets Point

Bill, Melinda Gates buy daughter a $5M pad at 1212 Fifth