U.S. Supreme Court seeks city’s input on UWS landlord’s rent-stabilization complaint

TRD New York /
Dec.December 20, 2011 09:27 AM

James Harmon, a former federal prosecutor who owns a townhouse on West 76th Street near Central Park, could be going before the U.S. Supreme Court to fight rent regulation.

The New York Times reported that Harmon has lost twice in lower courts, including in the Court of Appeals in Manhattan in September, but the Supreme Court has taken notice of the case and asked the city and state to file answers to Harmon’s petition to be heard.

Harmon, who lives on the parlor floor of the house and rents out the top floors as six one-bedroom apartments, claims that the rent laws are a “taking” of his property. The government locks him into earning a below market-rate for the units, and he shoulders that burden for generations as the apartments get passed down. The three rent-stabilized tenants pay around $1,000 a month for their homes, according to the Times.

Though tenants say Harmon is friendly, and he insists he is not personally attacking his tenants, the lawsuit could have major implications if, against all odds, it is successful. Rent-stabilization has been challenged several times through the years, but has found favor in courts. The lower courts that previously ruled against Harmon expect their decisions to stand.

Harmon dislikes that the rent-stabilization system is dependent on luck, rather than need, pointing out that one of his tenants owns a home on Long Island. But local assemblywoman Linda Rosenthal was quick to acknowledge Harmon’s luck in inheriting the townhouse in 1949 from his grandfather. [NYT]

Related Articles

Blackstone CEO Steven Schwartzman and Stuyvesant Town (Credit: Getty Images)

After authorities vowed review of Stuy Town deal, Blackstone changes course on vacancies

Real Capital Analytics data showed that New York’s multifamily market had a very slow July. (Credit: iStock)

New NYC rent law “beginning to shut down investment”

Some landlords say they plan to close the door to vacant apartments and wait for the laws to change (Credit: iStock)

Creative ways NYC landlords are getting around the new rent rules

Berlin, Germany (Credit: Getty Images, iStock)

Rent freeze in Berlin ends calls for expropriation, but may spark disinvestment

Governor Andrew Cuomo (Credit: Getty Images, iStock, and Pixabay)

Analysis: Here’s what the new rent law will do to the average stabilized apartment

(Credit: iStock)

“Indentured landlord” in rent-reg lawsuit vents at politicians

A&E Real Estate Holdings principal Douglas Eisenberg and the properties along Queens Blvd and 65th Avenue (Credit: The Rego Park 18 Portfolio)

A&E Real Estate buys huge rent-stabilized portfolio at deep discount

Clockwise from left: 5203-5207 Church Avenue in Brooklyn, 119-40 Metropolitan Avenue in Queens, 855 East 217th Street in the Bronx and 31-35 Steinway Street in Queens (Credit: Google Maps)

Going once, Going twice! Rent-stabilized portfolio hits auction block