DiNapoli says audit confirms “sweetheart” deal for Apple in Grand Central

New York /
Jul.July 30, 2012 10:00 AM

State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli’s promised audit of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s lease agreement with Apple at Grand Central Terminal revealed the sweetheart deal he expected to find, according to the New York Post.

DiNapoli discovered that — after negotiating with Apple for more than two years — the MTA required that bidders for the former Metrazur restaurant space front $5 million to consummate the lease. That was a benefit to the cash-rich technology manufacturer, according to DiNapoli, who said in the report set to be released today that “the competitive process followed by MTA … was at a minimum severely slanted toward Apple.”

MTA Chairman Joseph Lhota responded by saying, “This audit is not fact-based, and, accordingly, their opinion is worthless.”

While Apple pays four times what Metrazur paid for the space, DiNapoli said it is still well below market value and doesn’t include a revenue-sharing agreement as other leases in Grand Central do. That costs the MTA millions a year, according to real estate insiders.

But as previously reported, the presence of Apple has been a boon to the Grand Central retail space as a whole. [Post]


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
A photo illustration of Gov. Andrew Cuomo and Mayor Bill de Blasio (Getty)
Congress came through. Why is real estate not satisfied?
Congress came through. Why is real estate not satisfied?
Dalton Gomez and Ariana Grande (Compass, Getty, Instagram/ArianaGrande)
Ariana Grande and Compass’ Dalton Gomez engaged
Ariana Grande and Compass’ Dalton Gomez engaged
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (Getty)
Stimulus to extend eviction moratorium, provide $25B in rent relief
Stimulus to extend eviction moratorium, provide $25B in rent relief
The MTA board approved rent relief for small businesses in Grand Central and other locations (iStock)
MTA cuts rent up to 90% for small businesses
MTA cuts rent up to 90% for small businesses
(Getty)
MTA proposes percentage-based rent payments for Grand Central retailers
MTA proposes percentage-based rent payments for Grand Central retailers
TRD's Erik Engquist and MTA Chief Development Officer Janno Lieber 
MTA development chief: Capital budget will be “cannibalized” without federal aid
MTA development chief: Capital budget will be “cannibalized” without federal aid
Related chairman Steve Ross and 35 Hudson Yards (Photos via Getty, SOM, MTA)
Hudson Yards pad sells for $7M; cash-strapped MTA gets a cut
Hudson Yards pad sells for $7M; cash-strapped MTA gets a cut
From left: Port Authority Bus Terminal, Grand Central and Penn Station (Wikipedia, Pixabay, CDC)
TRD Insights: Focus may shift to Manhattan’s 3 transport hubs in post-Covid office market
TRD Insights: Focus may shift to Manhattan’s 3 transport hubs in post-Covid office market
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...