DiNapoli says audit confirms “sweetheart” deal for Apple in Grand Central

TRD New York /
Jul.July 30, 2012 10:00 AM

State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli’s promised audit of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s lease agreement with Apple at Grand Central Terminal revealed the sweetheart deal he expected to find, according to the New York Post.

DiNapoli discovered that — after negotiating with Apple for more than two years — the MTA required that bidders for the former Metrazur restaurant space front $5 million to consummate the lease. That was a benefit to the cash-rich technology manufacturer, according to DiNapoli, who said in the report set to be released today that “the competitive process followed by MTA … was at a minimum severely slanted toward Apple.”

MTA Chairman Joseph Lhota responded by saying, “This audit is not fact-based, and, accordingly, their opinion is worthless.”

While Apple pays four times what Metrazur paid for the space, DiNapoli said it is still well below market value and doesn’t include a revenue-sharing agreement as other leases in Grand Central do. That costs the MTA millions a year, according to real estate insiders.

But as previously reported, the presence of Apple has been a boon to the Grand Central retail space as a whole. [Post]


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
From left: Port Authority Bus Terminal, Grand Central and Penn Station (Wikipedia, Pixabay, CDC)

TRD Insights: Focus may shift to Manhattan’s 3 transport hubs in post-Covid office market

TRD Insights: Focus may shift to Manhattan’s 3 transport hubs in post-Covid office market
An Apple store at  767 5th Avenue (Credit: Wikipedia)

Apple closes most stores in effort to curb virus spread

Apple closes most stores in effort to curb virus spread
Joe Germanotta at Art Bird & Whiskey Bar and Lady Gaga (inset) (Photo by Stephanie Ott/picture alliance via Getty Images; Lady Gaga by Kevin Mazur/Getty Images for NARAS)

Lady Gaga’s dad, MTA in rent feud over homeless at Grand Central

Lady Gaga’s dad, MTA in rent feud over homeless at Grand Central
Steve Wynn and the Wynn Las Vegas Resort (Credit: Getty Images)

Disgraced casino mogul Wynn to pay $20M to settle shareholder suit

Disgraced casino mogul Wynn to pay $20M to settle shareholder suit
From left: 1800 and 1815 Park Avenue, MTA's Second Avenue Subway plan, and 160 East 125th Street between 3rd and Lexington (Credit: Google Maps)

Second Ave subway’s next phase could impact Durst, Extell dev sites

Second Ave subway’s next phase could impact Durst, Extell dev sites
Corey Johnson’s MTA reform plan targets controversial Scaffold Law

Corey Johnson’s MTA reform plan targets controversial Scaffold Law

Corey Johnson’s MTA reform plan targets controversial Scaffold Law
MTA renews 50K sf at Forest City’s 1 Pierrepont Plaza in Brooklyn

MTA renews 50K sf at Forest City’s
1 Pierrepont Plaza in Brooklyn

MTA renews 50K sf at Forest City’s
1 Pierrepont Plaza in Brooklyn
The MTA is still spending millions to maintain its empty headquarters

The MTA is still spending millions to maintain its empty headquarters

The MTA is still spending millions to maintain its empty headquarters
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...