Architecture Review — Lincoln Center footbridge is a weak link

Diller Scofidio + Renfro’s deconstructionist design spans 65th Street

New York /
Aug.August 10, 2012 02:30 PM

The newest installment in Diller Scofidio + Renfro’s reconceiving of Lincoln Center is the soon-to-be-completed bridge spanning 65th Street. As of this past week, the bridge looked to be substantially finished, although a bit of tarp and paper lay festooned around the sides. Even though the new structure is not one of the better elements of the revisions, it is infinitely better than what it replaces.

Having grown up in the vicinity of Lincoln Center, I always knew that stretch of 65th Street as the ugliest, most forbidding and forlorn part of the complex. Over a good part of the road extended the Paul Milstein plaza, a broad, graceless and mostly unnecessary expanse of masonry that was little enhanced by its being clad in travertine, the signature material that continues to cover most of Lincoln Center. Quite aside from the fact that the top of the bridge, 82 feet from north to south and 204 from east to west, was poorly conceived, underneath it the entire area was covered in sepulchral darkness for more than 40 years, and worse still, it was the main entrance to the colossal garage that served all of the performing arts complex. Beyond that garage there was nothing other than an unlovely side entrance to Juilliard.

Now, with the overhang removed, interesting architectural events have sprung up, from the restaurant Lincoln to a new movie theatre and a much improved and far more grandiose entrance to Juilliard.

As for the new bridge, it is a tiny sliver compared to what was there before. Done up in the deconstructivist mode, it bends and swerves irregularly. Even though this style is dear to the architects, given that they have used it elsewhere at Lincoln Center and farther afield, it looks especially inaesthetic hanging over West 65th street; it’s rather pointless, too. It appears to bifurcate as it approaches the southern side, but that is really a feint, since the western prong is really only for structural support, even though I strongly suspect that the architects resorted to it for aesthetic reasons, because it conformed to their wayward sense of style and design. Diller Scofidio + Renfro’s work at Lincoln Center has always been a mixed bag. Some elements, like the fountain in the middle of Josie Robertson Plaza and the opening up of the façade of Alice Tully Hall On Broadway have been spectacularly successful. Other contributions, like the reconceiving of the 65th Street side of Juilliard have been less so. The new bridge, unfortunately, appears to be the weakest part of the plan.

James Gardner is The Real Deal’s architecture critic.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
These are the tallest towers underway in NYC
These are the tallest towers underway
in NYC
These are the tallest towers underway
in NYC
A new competition asks what would houses on Mars look like (Credit: Getty Images, Pixabay)
Architecture’s final frontier: Here’s what houses on Mars might look like
Architecture’s final frontier: Here’s what houses on Mars might look like
 88 Meadow Lane in Southampton, Long Island (Google Maps, Getty)
Southampton’s demolition battle drags on for Norman Jaffe-designed home
Southampton’s demolition battle drags on for Norman Jaffe-designed home
From left: Gensler’s Joseph Lauro; Badaly Architecture’s Nima Badaly; 345 Park Avenue South; the development site at 2183 Morris Avenue in the Bronx (Getty, Gensler, LinkedIn/Nima Badaly, RFR, Google Maps)
These were NYC’s most active architects in 2022
These were NYC’s most active architects in 2022
Illustration of the Belmont Hotel in Dallas (Getty, Google Maps; Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
The lives and deaths of the Belmont Hotel
The lives and deaths of the Belmont Hotel
Rise of the renderer: How DBOX became the Ferrari of real estate marketing
Rise of the renderer: How DBOX became the Ferrari of real estate marketing
Rise of the renderer: How DBOX became the Ferrari of real estate marketing
Frank Lloyd Wright with 1425 Valley View Drive (Getty, Re/Max)
Unique Frank Lloyd Wright home available … for now
Unique Frank Lloyd Wright home available … for now
Bernheimer Architecture's Andrew Bernheimer (LinkedIn, Getty Images)
New York firm establishes architecture’s first union
New York firm establishes architecture’s first union
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...