Use of eminent domain to seize mortgages erodes basic lending principles: FHFA general counsel

New York /
Sep.September 21, 2012 09:30 AM

The general counsel for the Federal Housing Finance Agency has come out against a proposed plan to seize underwater mortgage by eminent domain, the Wall Street Journal reported. Alfred Pollard, who said he spoke for himself and not the FHFA, said the practice, proposed by municipalities and private investors would potentially erode the distinction between secured and unsecured lending.

“For 700 years in Anglo-American law, the use of property—collateral—to secure a loan was a contract that would be honored,” Pollard said at a Washington D.C. conference yesterday. The seizure of a mortgage, which is not real property, would call into question long-held distinctions between credit and collateral and could raise the cost of credit, Pollard said, according to the Journal.

The plan to use eminent domain was originally proposed by San Francisco-based investment firm Mortgage Resolution Partners and calls for local governments to buy mortgages at the fair market value of their corresponding homes. The government would then help the homeowner refinance the mortgage and unburden them from underwater loans, previous reports show. Ben Bernanke has dodged the matter; Yale economist Robert Shiller has supported it. [WSJ] — Guelda Voien

 

Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Appraisal gap worsened
Appraisal gap worsened as racial disparity persists
Appraisal gap worsened as racial disparity persists
Southold Town Supervisor Scott Russell and 12500 Main Road in Mattituck (Google Maps, Getty, Town of Southold)
North Fork town smells victory in eminent domain fight
North Fork town smells victory in eminent domain fight
Mahwah mayor Jim Wysocki and 1 International Boulevard and NJ-17 in Mahwah NJ (Google Maps, Facebook/Wysocki4Mayor, Getty)
Sheraton to Mahwah: We are not blighted
Sheraton to Mahwah: We are not blighted
Hoboken City Council's Michael Russo with 308 Willow Avenue (Google Maps, Hoboken, Getty)
Hoboken hospital eyed for eminent domain
Hoboken hospital eyed for eminent domain
A photo illustration of charter bus company North Fork Express (left), Tritec Real Estate's planned Ronkonkoma Hub project (middle) and Tritec Real Estate's principal Robert Coughlan (EverybodyWiki/Orenawong, Tritec Real Estate, iStock)
Holdout threatens massive Long Island development
Holdout threatens massive Long Island development
Town of Oyster Bay supervisor Joseph Saladino (Town of Oyster, Google Maps, iStock)
Owners reject offer for parking lot by LIRR, so town moves to seize it
Owners reject offer for parking lot by LIRR, so town moves to seize it
Photo Illustration of Douglas Durst, chairman of the Durst Organization (Getty)
Durst accuses MTA of stalling East Harlem development
Durst accuses MTA of stalling East Harlem development
Shares of Rocket Cos and LoanDepot rose while shares Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac plunged after Supreme Court ruling (Unsplash)
For mortgage sector stocks, Fannie and Freddie ruling was positive
For mortgage sector stocks, Fannie and Freddie ruling was positive
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...