Naftali sues UWS landlord over soured deal

Developer claims breach of fiduciary duties, asks for $2M in damages

New York /
Jan.January 25, 2013 04:30 PM

Updated: 6:27 p.m., Jan. 25

The Naftali Group has sued landlord Jack Benishai over an alleged breach of a letter of intent to sell two Upper West Side residential rental properties, according to Records Filed With The State Supreme Court. A request for further judicial intervention and a claim for compensatory damages of $2.12 million was made Tuesday, about two months after the initial lawsuit was filed.

The suit alleges that in April 2012, Naftali Group and Benishai executed a letter of intent for Benishai to sell a 50 percent stake in 250 West 76th Street — a four-story, 4,868-square-foot building and 252 West 76th — a 11-story, 50,600-square foot building for $12.5 million to the Naftali Group. The letter further established an “exclusivity period,” in which Benishai would refrain from negotiating with third parties to sell any interest in the buildings. The Naftali Group paid a $20,000 deposit for this exclusivity.

According to the Nov. 19 filing, Benishai “displayed little urgency to negotiate and finalize the contemplated transaction document,” until Naftali Group reached out to his brother, David Benishai with whom Benishai had an ongoing legal dispute relating to their co-ownership of their company, Ilan Properties. Naftali’s new agreement with Ilan Properties stated that it intended to purchase the entire property for $25 million.

But, the suit alleges, Benishai communicated with others during the exclusivity period, thereby breaching the letter of intent, and used the letter as leverage to obtain more money for the property. The suit claims that due to Benishai’s “foot dragging and inaction,” a party that Naftali was interested in bringing on board walked away from the deal, causing Naftali significant losses and putting their plans for the property into jeopardy.

“By his consistent course of conduct, it is abundantly clear that Jack Benishai did not engage in good faith negotiations with Naftali Group in order to consummate the proposed transaction,” the filing states.

Andrew Gold, an attorney for the Naftali Group, declined to comment on the suit.

The Naftali Group’s recent transactions include a $37 million purchase of a six-story Chelsea rental building from the Haruvi family. Miki Naftali, the chairman and CEO of the Naftali Group, was recently profiled by The Real Deal.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Naftali Group's Mika Naftali, Len Blavatnik and 470 Kent Avenue (Naftali Group, Google Maps, Mark Neyman / Government Press Office/CC BY-SA 3.0/via Wikimedia Commons)
Naftali, Blavatnik land $385M for big Williamsburg resi project
Naftali, Blavatnik land $385M for big Williamsburg resi project
A photo illustration of Adam Leitman Bailey (far left) and Miki Naftali (right) (Getty Images, Naftali Group, Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C.)
Naftali tenant suffers blow in holdout battle
Naftali tenant suffers blow in holdout battle
Naftali's Miki Naftali with 255 East 77th Street (Naftali Group, Google Maps)
Naftali files plans for UES building. Smart money’s on condos
Naftali files plans for UES building. Smart money’s on condos
From left: Adam Leitman Bailey P.C.'s Steven Wagner; Belkin Burden Goldman's Sherwin Belkin; Adam Leitman Bailey P.C.'s Adam Leitman Bailey; and Naftali Group’s Miki Naftali (Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal with Getty Images, Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C., Belkin Burden Goldman)
Pay up or lawyer up: What does a holdout cost a developer?
Pay up or lawyer up: What does a holdout cost a developer?
From left: Gary Barnett, with One Manhattan Square, Harry Macklow with One Wall Street, Steve Witkoff with One High Line, and Miki Naftali with 1045 Madison Avenue (Getty, One Manhattan Square, One Wall Street, Big Architects, The Benson)
Over the glut, but now what? Breaking down NYC’s new condo inventory
Over the glut, but now what? Breaking down NYC’s new condo inventory
Miki Naftali with 215 West 84th Street (Getty, Corcoran)
Naftali takes hit in battle with UWS holdout
Naftali takes hit in battle with UWS holdout
Miki Neftali and 215 West 84th Street (Getty)
Naftali moves to demolish UWS building with holdout tenant
Naftali moves to demolish UWS building with holdout tenant
Naftali Group's Miki Naftali, BRP Companies' Meredith Marshall (Photos by Paul Dilakian)
Miki Naftali, Meredith Marshall talk development, death of 421a
Miki Naftali, Meredith Marshall talk development, death of 421a
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...