Ashkenazy sues over $28M retail condo contract

Formerly Ollie’s restaurant, the space had been on the market for $39.5 million

New York /
May.May 03, 2013 04:00 PM

New York City-based real estate investment firm Ashkenazy Acquisition, headed by young mogul Ben Ashkenazy, has sued the owners of a retail condominium at 1991 Broadway, after signing a contract to pay $28 million for the property.

The family firm that owns the property claimed there was no special permit restricting use of the city-owned interior atrium with public seating at the building, according to the suit, filed April 26. In fact, Ashkenazy alleges, the permit not only existed but had been violated several times by the owners as recently as 2008, making them aware of its existence.

Ashkenazy Acquisition entered into a contract for the property, formerly home to Chinese eatery Ollie’s, in March, having submitted a $1 million deposit into escrow, the complaint says.

Alan Phillips, who heads the family-based company selling the property, told The Real Deal that Ashkenazy certainly knew of the special permit before making the deal. Phillips had been advised by his brokers to go for Ashkenazy’s deal over several other offers because the mogul would likely close quickly, he said.

“Before he went into contract, we told him to do all his due diligence, he said.”My position is that he was fully aware there was a special permit.”

Ashkenazy’s attorney, Kevin Nash, said the company would prefer to move forward with the deal but wants to “enforce the contract.” Ashkenazy himself did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The condo, between West 67th and West 68th streets, had been on the market since February and was marketed by Oklahoma-based commercial brokerage Stan Johnson Company, asking $39.5 million. Stan Johnson executives Jason Maier and Jeff Karp declined to comment on the suit.

The retail condo totals 7,500 square feet, including 3,000 square feet on the ground floor; 2,000 square feet on the mezzanine level; and 2,500 square feet in the basement, The Real Deal previously reported. Union Square Hospitality Group CEO Danny Meyer was reportedly eyeing the unit, at the base of the Bel-Canto condo building, for his new Upper East Side restaurant in January.

Phillips said he wanted to be careful not to “bad-mouth” Ashkenazy.

“I would say nothing about his character,” he said, “other than that he’s smarter than we are.”

Ashkenazy has asked the court to compel the seller to remove the special permit or return the company’s deposit, plus interest and damages to be determined by the judge.

If the special permit must remain in place, Ashkenazy wants the price of the property to be reduced to make up for the alleged drop in value caused by the existence of the permit. In the meantime, he wants the escrow agent to be prevented from releasing the deposit to the seller.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Ben Ashkenazy with 2067 Broadway (Google Maps, Getty)
Ashkenazy, Gindis face UWS foreclosure as feud drags on
Ashkenazy, Gindis face UWS foreclosure as feud drags on
Ben Ashkenazy with 660 Madison Ave
Louis Vuitton pop-up headed to former Barneys space
Louis Vuitton pop-up headed to former Barneys space
Ben Ashkenazy goes on the offensive
Ben Ashkenazy goes on the offensive
Ben Ashkenazy goes on the offensive
(photos by Joe Lovinger/The Real Deal)
Day 2 of ICSC: Retailers button up to network, prep for uncertain future
Day 2 of ICSC: Retailers button up to network, prep for uncertain future
Ben Ashkenazy (Corcoran)
Ashkenazy could lose another retail property to foreclosure
Ashkenazy could lose another retail property to foreclosure
Ben Ashkenazy dumps Midtown retail building at $6M loss
Ben Ashkenazy dumps Midtown retail building at $6M loss
Ben Ashkenazy dumps Midtown retail building at $6M loss
SL Green CEO Marc Holliday and Ashkenazy Aqcuisition’s Ben Ashkenazy and the property (Google Maps, SL Green)
SL Green snaps up Ashkenazy’s 690 Madison through foreclosure
SL Green snaps up Ashkenazy’s 690 Madison through foreclosure
690 Madison Avenue,SL Green CEO Marc Holliday and Ashkenazy Aqcuisition's Ben Ashkenazy (Photos via SL Green, Google Maps)
SL Green looks to foreclose on Ashkenazy’s 690 Madison
SL Green looks to foreclose on Ashkenazy’s 690 Madison
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...