Presenting a list of beasts banned from NYC apartments

Mountain lions, aardwolfs and other creatures a no-no, city says

TRD New York /
Jul.July 12, 2013 05:30 PM

Oliver Twist’s Mr. Bumble famously proclaimed that “the law is an ass.” But when it comes to New York City apartments, the law is also a panther, a mongoose, an aardwolf and hundreds of other exotic beasts, according to a Department of Health and Mental Hygiene list of forbidden pets reviewed by The Real Deal.

The extensive list – the city defines a wild animal as any “naturally inclined to do harm and capable of inflicting harm upon human beings” – includes creatures from around the world. There’s the zorille, an African relative of the weasel that resembles a skunk, for example, and the jaguarundi, a wildcat native to Latin America.

“People in New York have their ways of getting their hands on these animals,” said Stuart Slotnick, a managing partner at Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney, when asked why the city would take the pains to make such a detailed accounting. Slotnick first came across the list when a client, whom he declined to provide details about, went toe-to-toe in court with his landlord over one such critter.

Lots of New York landlords have a “no pets” rule, but Slotnick pointed out a clause in the law that residents can use to get around an animal-less existence. If a tenant can prove that Fido is essential to his emotional well-being, then the pooch gets a pass.

“Some residents get medical notes from their doctors prescribing them pets,” Slotnick said.

But any effort to use the loophole for a wild animal would be tranquilized pretty quickly, he added.

“It’s mostly dogs and cats,” Slotnick said. “No one has yet tried to get a cobra declared an emotional support pet.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
NYC Department of Health Commissioner Dr. Oxiris Barbot and the Harlem Hospital Center at 506 Lenox Ave with 22 West 137th Street (Credit: Barbot by Lev Radin/Pacific Press/LightRocket via Getty Images; Google Maps)

City moves forward with plans for $400M public health lab

City moves forward with plans for $400M public health lab
REBNY president Jim Whelan (right) and Council member Robert Cornegy (Credit: Getty Images and iStock)

REBNY asks city to help landlords pay for lead abatement

REBNY asks city to help landlords pay for lead abatement
City report shows lead levels 36x health standard at Delshah’s 138 Ludlow Street

City report shows lead levels 36x health standard at Delshah’s 138 Ludlow Street

City report shows lead levels 36x health standard at Delshah’s 138 Ludlow Street
NY agencies close to 250K sf renewal at 90 Church

NY agencies close to 250K sf renewal at 90 Church

NY agencies close to 250K sf renewal at 90 Church
Opera House Hotel is source of Legionnaires’ outbreak: city

Opera House Hotel is source of Legionnaires’ outbreak: city

Opera House Hotel is source of Legionnaires’ outbreak: city
Smokers at UWS condo fume over delay on ban vote

Smokers at UWS condo fume over delay on ban vote

Smokers at UWS condo fume over delay on ban vote
Clockwise from top: A jaguarundi, polar bears, a black mamba and a mountain lion

A “beastly” business: Queens has most illegal pet violations

A “beastly” business: Queens has most illegal pet violations
The site of the nursing home at West 97th Street (Credit: JHL)

UWSers question environmental review of nursing home

UWSers question environmental review of nursing home
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...