80-20 tax breaks seen as “most inefficient” housing program

New York /
Nov.November 01, 2013 09:30 AM

While the mayoral candidates agree that more affordable housing is needed in New York City, a debate rages on about how best to provide it.

Using the so-called 80-20 program, developers like Joseph Moinian have built subsidized housing into glassy new towers, such as a 656-foot tower at West 42nd Street at 11th Avenue that offers a basketball court and indoor and outdoor swimming pools. But housing advocates urge the city and developers alike to look into more pragmatic options — perhaps in less tony neighborhoods and with fewer bells and whistles.

City officials told the Wall Street Journal that market-rate buildings using 80-20 and comparable programs have provided about 6,470 affordable apartments since 2004. Critics say the tax-exempt bonds the city has access to — about $1.9 billion in bonds per year — are all being eaten up by that type of project, however, when other more affordable projects of greater numbers could be built.

“It is about the most inefficient way, from the taxpayer’s point of view, to provide affordable housing,” Benjamin Dulchin, executive director of the Association for Neighborhood and Housing Development, a coalition of nonprofit developers, told the Journal.

Developers, for their part, claim that help from tax-exempt bonds and other subsidies are the only way to make a project pencil out financially.

“We can’t make rental projects work without the benefits of inclusionary zoning, and tax exemptions,” Jon McMillan, an executive vice president of residential developer TF Cornerstone, told the Journal. TF Cornerstone is currently seeking approval to build a Far West Side tower with 1,189 apartments, including 238 affordable units, the Journal said.

“We are doing the most common thing developers are doing now,” he said. [WSJ] — Guelda Voien


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Zoe Elghanayan, vice president, TF Cornerstone, along with The Berkley at 223 North 8th Street in North Williamsburg (Gad Realty NYC, TF Cornerstone)
TF Cornerstone nabs North Williamsburg rental for $71M
TF Cornerstone nabs North Williamsburg rental for $71M
175 Park Avenue with RXR Realty's Scott Rechler and TF Cornerstone’s Frederick Elghanayan (SOM Architects, Getty, TF Cornerstone)
RXR, TF Cornerstone cleared for 1,500-foot tower at Grand Central
RXR, TF Cornerstone cleared for 1,500-foot tower at Grand Central
TF Cornerstone president Fredrick Elghanayan and 595 Dean Street (TF Cornerstone, rendering via MOSO Studio)
TF Cornerstone scores $385M loan for Prospect Heights apartment towers
TF Cornerstone scores $385M loan for Prospect Heights apartment towers
Renderings of 175 Park Avenue (Rendering via SOM)
Developers unveil plans for 1,600-foot tower at Grand Central
Developers unveil plans for 1,600-foot tower at Grand Central
TF Cornerstone president Fredrick Elghanayan and an aerial of 54-01, 54-19 2nd Street in Long Island City (Credit: TF Cornerstone and Google Maps)
No Amazon, no problem: TF Cornerstone plans 1,400 apartments in LIC
No Amazon, no problem: TF Cornerstone plans 1,400 apartments in LIC
Clockwise from top left: 190 Beach 69th Street, 47-20 Center Boulevard and 2505 Bruckner Boulevard
These were the top outer borough loans last month
These were the top outer borough loans last month
The Real Deal interviews TF Cornerstone's Tom Elghanayan at REBNY's 124th annual banquet.
TF Cornerstone exec: How I got over Amazon dumping LIC
TF Cornerstone exec: How I got over Amazon dumping LIC
From left: Jim Whelan, David Schechtman, Tom Elghanayan, Helena Durst, Bill Rudin, and Adam Leitman Bailey
Real estate bigwigs sound off on politics at REBNY gala
Real estate bigwigs sound off on politics at REBNY gala
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...