Blackstone’s rental-backed securities revolutionary: Shiller

TRD New York /
Nov.November 04, 2013 04:12 PM

Private equity giant Blackstone has been a massive force in the U.S. housing market, buying up thousands of foreclosed homes and converting them to rental properties.

Yesterday, the FT’s Tracy Alloway and Anjili Raval reported that Blackstone will launch a “novel security”  this week that will pay investors with the rental income coming from these properties. This caught the attention of newly-minted Nobel Prize winner and housing markets guru Robert Shiller for his opinion, who Tweeted that this could “mark a revolution.”

We reached out to Shiller for more color.

“I am excited to hear about this new possibility,” he responded.

Shiller told us he believes this would provide the market with more current and accurate pricing information, thus making the housing market much more efficient.

“My first thought is that this securitization might develop the markets further, and that the two markets might support each other,” he added.

“On a deeper level, regardless of its impact on the futures market, if the REO to rental securities take hold, and become liquid, it may increase the efficiency of the market for single-family homes,” he added. “That market has been extraordinarily inefficient, as [Karl] Case and I showed in an American Economic Review article 25 years ago. Momentum persists for years. That would all change if professionals could really play a liquid market, and did so on a large scale.”

Housing market derivatives are not news to Shiller. In 2006, Shiller and Case collaborated with S&P and the Chicago Mercantile Exchange to launch a futures contract on single-family homes.

“That contract is still going today, though weakly, see homepricefutures.com, a site maintained by John Dolan,” he told us.

Indeed, these contracts sound like a good idea in theory, but in practice they haven’t been very successful.

“[T]here may be difficulties actually finding a market for these securities, as there was for the securitization of shared appreciation mortgages (SAM) in the 1990s,” said Shiller.

Those SAM mortgages occurred when a lender agreed to receive a lower interest rate in exchange for a percentage of the appreciation of the house at the time of sale. They failed to catch on because, when they were first proposed in the U.S. in the late 90’s, no one was worried about price declines, according to Harvard Business School’s Robin Greenwood and Luis Viceira.

Reuters’ Adam Tempkin reported last week that prospective investors pitched by Blackstone were fairly receptive to the new security, although they apparently had some concern about whether Blackstone had enough “skin in the game,” as well as overly optimistic “broker price opinions,” or BPOs, of current home values.

Given that Shiller has recently said he’s starting to see signs of another bubble, it may be in everyone’s interest to increase efficiency as soon as possible.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Blackstone COO Jonathan Gray and Club Quarters Chicago at 111 W Adams Street (Getty, Google)

Blackstone misses payment on $274M hotel loan

Blackstone misses payment on $274M hotel loan
Blackstone’s Jonathan Gray

TRD Insights: Here’s how much tenants pay for space at Blackstone’s massive industrial portfolio

TRD Insights: Here’s how much tenants pay for space at Blackstone’s massive industrial portfolio
Blackstone’s Jonathan Gray, Starwood Capital Group’s Barry Sternlicht, and Oaktree Capital co-chairman Howard Marks (Getty)

“Phenomenal returns” for some distressed real estate investors in stocks

“Phenomenal returns” for some distressed real estate investors in stocks
Hudson Commons and 444 N. Michigan Ave. 

TRD Insights: Can CLOs recover from the pandemic?

TRD Insights: Can CLOs recover from the pandemic?
Blackstone's president Jonathan Gray and CEO Stephen Schwarzman (Credit: Gray via Drew Angerer/Getty Images; Schwarzman via Himanshu Bhatt/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

Blackstone: “We don’t need financing to get things done”

Blackstone: “We don’t need financing to get things done”
Blackstone’s Jonathan Gray and Starwood Capital Group’s Barry Sternlicht (Credit: Gray by  Drew Angerer/Getty Images; Sternlicht by Cindy Ord/Getty Images for 1 Hotels)

Blackstone, Starwood pick up stakes in Extended Stay America

Blackstone, Starwood pick up stakes in Extended Stay America
Clockwise from bottom left: 62-60 99th Street in Rego Park, 850-870 Third Avenue in Sunset Park and Square Mile Capital’s Craig Solomon with renderings of 550 Clinton Avenue in Brooklyn (Credit: Google Maps; Getty Images; Morris Adjmi Architects)

These were the top outer borough loans last month

These were the top outer borough loans last month
Blackstone's Jonathan Gray, Gaedeke Group's Sabine Gaedeke Stener and 44 Wall Street (Credit: Stener by Gaedeke Group; Gray by Drew Angerer/Getty Images, 44 Wall Street via Google Maps)

Blackstone sells office tower at 44 Wall Street for $200M

Blackstone sells office tower at 44 Wall Street for $200M
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...