NYT critic gets heat for touting more public review for towers

New York /
Dec.December 26, 2013 02:02 PM

If city agencies and community groups were granted more authority on air rights transfers for all new skyscrapers, it would unnecessarily add more hurdles to the approvals process, writes Reuters finance journalist Felix Salmon.

Salmon’s column was directed at New York Times architecture critic Michael Kimmelman and other writers who advocated limiting the role of private builders and expanding the public review component in the construction of tall buildings in New York City.

“Skyscrapers are a perfect emblem of capitalism — they destroy what came before, in order to create something new,” Salmon wrote. “Sometimes the change is for the better, and sometimes it’s for the worse — but a city where nothing new gets built is a dead city, which might have nostalgic value to tourists, but which is never going to be a driver of global commerce.”

Air rights acquisitions that are carried out through a zoning lot merger are currently not subject to public scrutiny.

Kimmelman also backed a requirement that developers “give something back” in exchange for permission to buy these air rights, such as affordable housing and contributions to transit improvements. He pointed to One57 as an example of what’s wrong – but Salmon said he is also not a fan of the Extell Development tower.

“Better we have a living city with a couple of less-than-perfect buildings, than a stifled one governed by nostalgists and Nimbys,” Salmon wrote. [Reuters]Mark Maurer


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Bruce Teitelbaum; West 145th Street and Lenox Avenue (Getty, Google Maps)
Bruce Teitelbaum reboots controversial Harlem project
Bruce Teitelbaum reboots controversial Harlem project
Benjamin Franklin wearing a santa hat over New York skyline
Housing solution: “Pay” pols who approve projects
Housing solution: “Pay” pols who approve projects
Wuhan Greenland Center rendering (Courtesy Adrian Smith + Gordon Gill Architecture)
Here are the 5 tallest skyscrapers to be completed in 2023
Here are the 5 tallest skyscrapers to be completed in 2023
Zara's Amancio Ortega (Illustration by Kevin Cifuentes for The Real Deal with Getty Images, Amazon.com, Inc./Public domain/via Wikimedia Commons)
Zara founder, Amazon spend big on Seattle housing
Zara founder, Amazon spend big on Seattle housing
Bruce Teitelbaum and Kristin Richardson Jordan with a rendering of the truck depot sign scheduled for installation Thursday at the site of a rejected housing development in Harlem. (Getty)
Bruce wasn’t bluffing: Truck depot opening at scuttled housing site
Bruce wasn’t bluffing: Truck depot opening at scuttled housing site
A photo illustration of Mayor of New York City Eric Adams (Getty)
Adams’ first rezoning plan centers on 46-block stretch of the Bronx
Adams’ first rezoning plan centers on 46-block stretch of the Bronx
From left: Ken Griffin, Steven Roth and Bill Rudin (Getty Images, iStock)
Ken Griffin to master lease Vornado, Rudin properties
Ken Griffin to master lease Vornado, Rudin properties
A photo illustration of Mayor of New York City Eric Adams (Getty)
Eric Adams proposes 6K new units near Bronx commuter stations
Eric Adams proposes 6K new units near Bronx commuter stations
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...