NYT critic gets heat for touting more public review for towers

New York /
Dec.December 26, 2013 02:02 PM

If city agencies and community groups were granted more authority on air rights transfers for all new skyscrapers, it would unnecessarily add more hurdles to the approvals process, writes Reuters finance journalist Felix Salmon.

Salmon’s column was directed at New York Times architecture critic Michael Kimmelman and other writers who advocated limiting the role of private builders and expanding the public review component in the construction of tall buildings in New York City.

“Skyscrapers are a perfect emblem of capitalism — they destroy what came before, in order to create something new,” Salmon wrote. “Sometimes the change is for the better, and sometimes it’s for the worse — but a city where nothing new gets built is a dead city, which might have nostalgic value to tourists, but which is never going to be a driver of global commerce.”

Air rights acquisitions that are carried out through a zoning lot merger are currently not subject to public scrutiny.

Kimmelman also backed a requirement that developers “give something back” in exchange for permission to buy these air rights, such as affordable housing and contributions to transit improvements. He pointed to One57 as an example of what’s wrong – but Salmon said he is also not a fan of the Extell Development tower.

“Better we have a living city with a couple of less-than-perfect buildings, than a stifled one governed by nostalgists and Nimbys,” Salmon wrote. [Reuters]Mark Maurer


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Extell sells One57 sponsor unit for $17M
Extell sells One57 sponsor unit for $17M
Extell sells One57 sponsor unit for $17M
Rendering of H Hotel, slated for 58 West 39th Street (Peter Poon Architects)
Heavy hangover: Air rights purchased for massive cantilever
Heavy hangover: Air rights purchased for massive cantilever
A rendering of 250 Water Street, Landmarks Preservation Commission chair Sarah Carroll and Howard Hughes Corporation CEO David O’Reilly (Center for Architecture, The Howard Hughes Corporation/SOM)
Howard Hughes told to further refine Seaport tower proposal
Howard Hughes told to further refine Seaport tower proposal
Judge Katherine Levine and Mayor Bill de Blasio (Levine via Facebook; Getty)
De Blasio admin at crossroads with Gowanus rezoning suit
De Blasio admin at crossroads with Gowanus rezoning suit
City attorneys say an executive order signed by Mayor Bill de Blasio should spell the end of a lawsuit holding up the Gowanus rezoning (Getty/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
De Blasio wades into Gowanus rezoning, seeks dismissal of lawsuit
De Blasio wades into Gowanus rezoning, seeks dismissal of lawsuit
One57's unit 51B (left) and unit 32C with Extell’s Gary Barnett (One57 photos via StreetEasy)
One57 resident pays $5.2M to swap 2-bed for duplex
One57 resident pays $5.2M to swap 2-bed for duplex
Public Advocate Jumaane Williams introduced the bill in May of 2019. (Jumaane Williams)
City Council bill demands racial disparity study for some rezonings
City Council bill demands racial disparity study for some rezonings
Extell CEO Gary Barnett pictured with One57. (Extell, One57)
One57 condo sells at record 51% loss
One57 condo sells at record 51% loss
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...