Morgan Stanley: We don’t see housing bubbles

New York /
Feb.February 02, 2014 03:00 PM

 Economist Robert Shiller warned all of us of the U.S. housing market bubble before the bubble eventually burst.

So, people took notice when Shiller said that some local housing markets in the U.S. were looking “bubbly.” He’s pointed his finger repeatedly and specifically to Phoenix and Las Vegas where prices have roared back. The credit analysts at Morgan Stanley, however, disagree with these concerns.

“While there are clear geographical variations in the pace of recovery, we do not find ‘bubbles’ across a wide range of regional housing markets,” wrote analysts led by Vishwanath Tirupattur. They begin their argument by noting that home prices nationally are 19.94% below their peaks.

“While we do not suggest that the pre-crisis peaks were not bubbly, the fact that we are almost 20% below levels attained eight years ago tells us that, at least at the national level, it would be hard to categorize the rise in home prices as a bubble,” they wrote.

This is the framework they use to defend today’s hotter metropolitan statistical areas (MSA).

“[T]he MSAs that endured the most serious declines in home prices have also rebounded the most. Home prices in MSAs such as Las Vegas, Phoenix and Miami – now regarded as the banner cities for pre-crisis ebullience for housing, recording declines in the 50%+ range – have shown notable rebounds, with price increases in the 30-45% range. Still, they are 35-45% below their pre-crisis peaks. Of the 20 MSAs we look at in Exhibit 1, San Francisco stands out, with a near 50% appreciation in prices since the trough. Still, it is 18.06% below its pre-crisis peak…”

“Besides illustrating the non-symmetric nature of arithmetic averages, this helps to show that, even at a more granular level, the bubble talk seems premature, in our view,” they wrote.

Unfortunately, asset price bubbles never look like bubbles until after they burst.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
(Getty)
Weekly home listings hit record low
Weekly home listings hit record low
The year-over-year rise in home prices was just below the 19.8 percent annual rise in August. (iStock)
Home prices up 20%, but buyers, take heart
Home prices up 20%, but buyers, take heart
The report shows the small uptick among single-family homes, townhomes, condominiums and co-ops. (iStock)
After rebound, existing home sales growth slows in October
After rebound, existing home sales growth slows in October
(iStock)
Manufactured home construction projected to hit 15-year high
Manufactured home construction projected to hit 15-year high
So much for that lull: bubble worries return for Canadian property
So much for that lull: bubble worries return for Canadian property
So much for that lull: bubble worries return for Canadian property
(L-R) Four Seasons Sotheby’s International Realty's Gary DiMauro, Redfin's New York market manager Matthew Frary; Four Seasons Sotheby’s International Realty President Laurie Mecier-Brochu and CEO Alan DiStasio are expanding their Hudson Valley footprint (Redfin, Four Seasons Sotheby’s International Realty)
Battle for Hudson Valley heats up as Sotheby’s, Redfin seek to cash in
Battle for Hudson Valley heats up as Sotheby’s, Redfin seek to cash in
Click, bid, buy: Suffolk County breaks precedent with virtual auction
Click, bid, buy: Suffolk County breaks precedent with virtual auction
Click, bid, buy: Suffolk County breaks precedent with virtual auction
(iStock/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
Moves hit 73-year low despite so-called pandemic migration
Moves hit 73-year low despite so-called pandemic migration
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...