DelShah throws in the towel on Flatiron Hotel suit

Toshi Chan wins out as Michael Shah puts an end to litigation

TRD New York /
Feb.February 17, 2014 09:15 AM

Real estate investor Robert “Toshi” Chan said he plans to move forward on his controversial hospitality and entertainment business after turnaround specialist DelShah Capital gave up it’s long-running court battle to take control of the Flatiron Hotel.

DelShah, led by chief executive Michael Shah, withdrew a legal maneuver to take control of The Boutique Property After A State Supreme Court judge signaled plans to rule again in favor of the hotel owners.

“The mortgage has been paid off and the foreclosure discontinued ,” Shah told The Real Deal in an emailed statement. “The litigation over the contract has currently been settled.”

Hudson Realty Capital, a Manhattan-based fund led by David Loo and Richard Ortiz, refinanced the debt, according to Shah and confirmed through documents filed Dec. 30 with the New York City Department of Finance.

DelShah fought a pitched battle to take over the boutique hotel at 1141 Broadway, after acquiring the defaulted $8 million mortgage debt and later entering a $31 million deal to buy the property from George Hourani. DelShah did the deal with Hourani, the head of construction firm Born to Build, in May 2013, after that contractor won a $3 million court judgment from Ibrahim Saleh, who DelShah says was a member of the hotel’s ownership group.

In December, the remaining owners of the Flatiron filed a motion to dismiss the suit, claiming that the judgment against Saleh, who fled the country following a federal conviction on an unrelated fraud case, could not be enforced. Jagdish Vaswani, one of the hotel’s owners, argued that the hotel sale was invalid, because Saleh was not authorized make decisions for the property.

“Put simply, DelShah’s action is an attempt to force the true owner of the Flatiron Hotel [Vaswani] to sell to DelShah the property based upon a purported agreement which was signed by someone who does not own the property and therefore had no authority to enter into the agreement,” said attorney Ronald Francis, in a Feb. 5 court filing.

In a settlement agreement dated Feb. 10, DelShah withdrew the complaint and canceled the notice of pendency against the hotel, and agreed to pay $10,000 in legal fees to the hotel owners. According to the agreement, DelShah does not admit any wrongdoing.

Shah told The Real Deal that he still believes “that there is ample evidence” that Saleh is the true owner of the hotel, but admits that the judge was about to throw the case out.

Meanwhile, Toshi, who managed the hotel through a lease deal with the owners, said he plans to continue running the hotel, noting he will expand his hospitality business. Last year, Toshi agreed to pay $1 million to settle a lawsuit with the city of New York over his illegal extended stay hotel business.

“The end of all of the litigation surrounding the Flatiron Hotel means I can now expand my hospitality and entertainment business on solid ground,” said Toshi. “The seller, Jay Vaswaini, honored his deal to me despite intense pressure and at great cost.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
(iStock)

Half empty or half full? Hotel occupancy rate nears 50%

Half empty or half full? Hotel occupancy rate nears 50%
Delshah Capital's Michael Shah, 58-60 Ninth Avenue and Urban Outfitters CEO Richard Hayne (Google Maps)

Delshah sues retailer Free People for $11M after terminating Meatpacking lease

Delshah sues retailer Free People for $11M after terminating Meatpacking lease
The W Hotel at 8 Albany Street (Google, Facebook)

W Hotel in downtown Manhattan closes forever

W Hotel in downtown Manhattan closes forever
Robert De Niro and 377 Greenwich Street (Getty, Google Maps)

Robert De Niro says Nobu, Greenwich Hotel are struggling

Robert De Niro says Nobu, Greenwich Hotel are struggling
The economy beat expectations in June, adding 4.8 million jobs, with retail and hospitality leading the way. But a surge in coronavirus infections threatens further gains. (Getty)

Retail and hospitality led June job gains as virus surged

Retail and hospitality led June job gains as virus surged
Alex Sapir with the NoMo Soho hotel at 9 Crosby Street (Nomo Soho)

Sapir Corp’s earnings highlight challenges facing NYC hotels

Sapir Corp’s earnings highlight challenges facing NYC hotels
The rate of job loss in America has stabilized, even though businesses continue to hemorrhage employees at unprecedented levels. (iStock)

Unemployment filings stabilize — but at record highs

Unemployment filings stabilize — but at record highs
GFI Capital CEO Allen Gross and the James Hotel at 22 East 29th Street (Google Maps)

GFI Capital takes majority stake in James Hotel in $110M deal

GFI Capital takes majority stake in James Hotel in $110M deal
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...