Newly opened WTC PATH train station criticized for design

Architect Santiago Calatrava blames cost-cutting measures for "cheap" appearance

New York /
Mar.March 05, 2014 06:00 PM

A section of the new PATH train station beneath the World Trade Center, open to the public for less than a week, is already under fire for its design.

The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey sought to model the underground transit hub after Grand Central Terminal, but the New York Times’ David Dunlap opines that the station does not live up to its expectations, calling the building’s fixtures “clunky” and the workmanship “rough.”

Architect Santiago Calatrava, meanwhile, has distanced himself from the $4 billion project, claiming he mostly designed the steel support structure and the marble floors.

“We have fought to bring the highest degree of quality to the project,” Frank Lotrino, another employee at Calatrava’s firm, told the Times, “but the concerns of time, budget and scheduling have often taken precedence over quality.”

The rest of the plan was drawn up by a partnership between architectural and engineering firms STV and Aecom. The station’s columns are not as seamless, nor the ceiling as sculptural as they appear in the renderings, Dunlap writes, because of compromises the firm made to reduce costs and necessary amenities like security cameras and smoke exhaust grills.

It is unclear whether the design will affect the value of the retail space within the hub, which is currently estimated at $550 per square foot[NYT] Angela Hunt


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
130 Liberty Street (Rendering via DBOX and KPF)
The quixotic quest to make WTC tower 100% affordable
The quixotic quest to make WTC tower 100% affordable
One World Trade Center with Constellation Agency co-founders Diana Lee and Matt Woodruff (iStock, Constellation Agency)
Constellation Agency leases 21st floor of One WTC
Constellation Agency leases 21st floor of One WTC
Victoria's Secret CEO John Mehas. (Getty)
Westfield sues Victoria’s Secret over WTC mall location
Westfield sues Victoria’s Secret over WTC mall location
CBRE CEO Robert Sulentic and One World Trade Center (CBRE, iStock)
Port Authority taps CBRE to manage WTC
Port Authority taps CBRE to manage WTC
Silverstein Properties’ Larry Silverstein and Brookfield’s Brian Kingston (Getty/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
Port Authority taps Silverstein, Brookfield to build 5WTC
Port Authority taps Silverstein, Brookfield to build 5WTC
Douglas Durst of the Durst Organization, Port Authority Executive Director Rick Cotton, and Conde Nast CEO Roger Lynch. (Getty)
Condé Nast isn’t paying rent at 1WTC amid lease dispute
Condé Nast isn’t paying rent at 1WTC amid lease dispute
Condé Nast CEO Roger Lynch and Durst Organization chairman Douglas Durst (Getty, iStock)
Condé Nast considers move to Gold Coast to save money
Condé Nast considers move to Gold Coast to save money
Uber CEO Dara Khosrowshahi and 3 World Trade Center (Getty)
Uber looks to sublet 25% of its 3 World Trade Center office
Uber looks to sublet 25% of its 3 World Trade Center office
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...