Long Island College Hospital backers ask judge to toss scores

Attorney says rating system rewarding proposals that kept facility open was ignored

New York /
Jun.June 04, 2014 04:00 PM

Community groups are asking a judge to throw out the scores submitted by several panel members tasked with choosing a winning bidder for SUNY’s Long Island College Hospital.

The advocates for LICH say the panel members in question did not follow the rules stipulated in the Request for Proposal process. As a result, they charge, bids that would keep a medical facility on the current site were awarded lower scores than they should have been.

The RFP rules originally stated that bids would qualify for a higher score if they provided for a full-service hospital with 100 inpatient beds, reports the Brooklyn Eagle. Proposals that did not include medical facilities were “subject to receiving a lower technical score.” Lawyers for SUNY said panelists were not mandated to award a certain number of points for hospital projects.

An attorney for the advocates, Jim Walden, Asked Supreme Court Justice Johnny Lee Baynes on Tuesday to consider as a litmus test a panelist identified as “Judge 9.” That panelist gave no points to the only four bids that met the hospital threshold, Walden said — yet awarded the full 70 points to a proposal that did not.

Community groups, unions and New York City public advocate Letitia James chose the panelists for a second RFP process in March. The goal of that panel was to keep the LICH operating as a hospital. [Brooklyn Eagle] — Tom DiChristopher


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Cobble Hill residents are complaining about a sharp whistling noise coming from a luxury condo at 347 Henry Street. (Douglas Elliman, Getty)
A shrill in Cobble Hill: Eerie noise from condo tower haunts locals
A shrill in Cobble Hill: Eerie noise from condo tower haunts locals
Carroll Gardens and Flatbush in Brooklyn (Photos by Steven Pisano via Flickr; Mrbrklyn via Wikipedia; iStock)
Brooklyn’s most and least expensive neighborhoods
Brooklyn’s most and least expensive neighborhoods
198 Warren Street and 1 Clinton Street in Brooklyn (Google Maps; One Clinton BK)
Only four Brooklyn lux deals for fifth time in six weeks
Only four Brooklyn lux deals for fifth time in six weeks
38 Hicks Street and 58 Butler Street in Brooklyn (Credit: Google Maps)
Brooklyn’s luxury resi market sees big dropoff in activity
Brooklyn’s luxury resi market sees big dropoff in activity
Renovations plans for the BQE would give nearby real estate a big boost, sources say. (Credit: Getty Images)
BQE project would yield Brooklyn real estate boon: locals
BQE project would yield Brooklyn real estate boon: locals
31 Schermerhorn Street and 234 Clinton Street in Brooklyn (Credit: Google Maps, StreetEasy) 
Another Cobble Hill townhouse is Brooklyn’s priciest contract of the week
Another Cobble Hill townhouse is Brooklyn’s priciest contract of the week
355 Henry Street
Cobble Hill townhouse was Brooklyn’s priciest contract last week
Cobble Hill townhouse was Brooklyn’s priciest contract last week
166 Amity Street and 210 Pacific Street in Brooklyn (Credit: StreetEasy)
Cobble Hill townhouse is again priciest Brooklyn contract
Cobble Hill townhouse is again priciest Brooklyn contract
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...