SL Green’s 1 Vanderbilt gets mixed reviews at Landmarks meeting

Some commissioners lauded design, others chided "hollow gesture" to Grand Central Terminal

New York /
Jul.July 22, 2014 04:15 PM

Opinions on SL Green’s 1 Vanderbilt were mixed at a meeting on Tuesday of the Landmarks and Preservation Commission, which sought to weigh in on the design of the 65-story building’s base and its effect on Grand Central Terminal.

James von Klemperer represented building architect Kohn Pederson Fox at the meeting, pointing out new views of the Terminal afforded by a set back and the inclusion of terra cotta to complement Grand Central, Curbed reported.

The majority of the commission, including chair Meenakshi Srinivasan, came out in favor of the design. Commissioner Michael Devonshire called it “well thought-out,” according to the news site, and fellow commissioner Margery Perlmutter said the existence of current buildings that tower over the Terminal do not harm it. Community Board 5 also sent a letter to the commission in support of 1 Vanderbilt.

Despite describing the tower design itself as “wonderful,” Commissioner Frederick Bland said it distracted from the station, according to the news site. The Historic Districts Council said it failed to achieve harmony with the Terminal, calling the cut-away feature at the base “a hollow gesture to the grandeur of the Terminal.” [Curbed]Tom DiChristopher


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
The Strand Bookstore and store owner Nancy Bass Wyden (Credit: Getty Images)
Over owner’s protests, city landmarks Strand bookstore
Over owner’s protests, city landmarks Strand bookstore
SL Green snags private-equity firm at One Vanderbilt
SL Green snags private-equity firm at One Vanderbilt
SL Green snags private-equity firm at One Vanderbilt
Revamped design for 550 Madison receives Landmarks’ approval
Revamped design for 550 Madison receives Landmarks’ approval
Revamped design for 550 Madison receives Landmarks’ approval
A rendering of 250 Water Street, Landmarks Preservation Commission chair Sarah Carroll and Howard Hughes Corporation CEO David O’Reilly (Center for Architecture, The Howard Hughes Corporation/SOM)
Howard Hughes told to further refine Seaport tower proposal
Howard Hughes told to further refine Seaport tower proposal
Howard Hughes Corporation CEO David O’Reilly and 250 Water Street (The Howard Hughes Corporation/SOM)
Critics look down on shorter 250 Water Street
Critics look down on shorter 250 Water Street
Previous rendering of 250 Water Street (left) and a new rendering (right) with Howard Hughes Corporation CEO David O’Reilly (The Howard Hughes Corporation/SOM)
Howard Hughes hopes smaller Seaport project will work this time
Howard Hughes hopes smaller Seaport project will work this time
The Down Town Association at 60-64 Pine Street (Wikipedia Commons, iStock/Illustration by Alexis Manrodt for The Real Deal)
Down Town Association files for bankruptcy
Down Town Association files for bankruptcy
Claudio Del Vecchio has owned Brooks Brothers since 2001. (Getty)
Brooks Brothers’ Madison Ave store could give way to Midtown East tower
Brooks Brothers’ Madison Ave store could give way to Midtown East tower
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...