Judge tosses suit from opponents of Willets Point deal

Court rules city's parkland lease for $3B mega-mall project did not violate state law

TRD New York /
Aug.August 20, 2014 03:40 PM

UPDATED, 4:42 p.m., Aug. 20: A New York state Supreme Court judge rejected a lawsuit this week from opponents of the Willets Point mega-mall redevelopment who claimed that it violated state law.

A group including State Senator Tony Avella and City Club of New York argued that the city broke the law when it planned to lease parkland to developers Related Companies and Fred Wilpon’s Sterling Equities. The plaintiffs allege that the  Uniform Land Use Review Procedure was not properly executed. Lawyer John Low-Beer represented those who filed suit. 

Judge Manuel Mendez found that there was no violation of the public trust and no need for injunctive relief.

“It has been established that ULURP [Uniform Land Use Review Procedure] does not apply to the development plans and review of the business terms for the disposition of the parkland formerly used for Shea Stadium,” Mendez wrote in his decision. These powers have devolved to [Mayor Bill de Blasio] who has approved the development plan.”

A spokesperson for Related and Sterling – also known as the Queens Development Group – Said The Court decision marks another victory for the project.

“The ruling is unequivocal in saying that the project is consistent with state law and rejecting every argument to the contrary,” the developers said in a joint statement. “More important, the decision reinforces the support that the City Council and a wide array of community stakeholders have given to this project.”

The plaintiffs that filed the suit could not be immediately reached for comment. The group plans to appeal the decision, according to the blog A Walk in the Park.

The $3 billion plan includes residential space and a mega mall and is set to displace hundreds of car repair shops located in the area. The developers plans to overhaul the 23-acre site it bought from the city for $1 in 2013. Two acres have already been transferred to the developers. The City Council approved the project in October, as previously reported.

Related Articles


Related is the latest developer to target the Rockaways

15 Hudson Yards (Credit: Related-Oxford, iStock)

First he sold a plot of land to Hudson Yards’ developers. Now he owns 7 luxury condos there

The Plaza Hotel in 1975 and models walking the runway during New York Fashion Week September 2019 (Credit: Getty Images)

Fashion Week struts its stuff at these iconic NYC locations

Related CEO Jeff Blau, Deutsche Bank CEO Christian Sewing, and Time Warner Center at 10 Columbus Circle (Credit: Getty Images and Wikipedia)

Deutsche Bank shrinks footprint at future Columbus Circle home amid global downsizing

Gym chain creator looks to part ways with Westchester County compound

1065-1075 Gerard Avenue in the Bronx 

Prana pays Related $36M in Bronx multifamily play

These are some of the most notable resi sales of the week

Clockwise from top: Related chairman Steven Ross, Mactaggart Family & Partners CEO Philip Mactaggart, a rendering of 456 Greenwich Street, and Caspi Development's Joshua Caspi (Credit: Getty Images, Mactaggart, and MHA Westchester)

Developers of bankrupt Tribeca hotel project think Related might be colluding with their landlord