Why Forest City’s modular design may not be the future

Stalled B2 BKLYN tower raising questions about feasibility of large pre-fab construction

New York /
Oct.October 27, 2014 10:01 AM

The stalled modular tower in Brooklyn has industry insiders asking the question: is modular construction at a large scale possible?

Construction of B2 BKLYN, a proposed tower built in the lego-esque modular technology, is at a standstill after developer Forest City Ratner Companies and construction company Skanska USA sued each other. While Forest City blames the execution of the plan, Skanska claimed the design was faulty, according to the Wall Street Journal. The work was shut down with only 10 stories built.

Skanska claimed, in a letter in which the company describes its frustrations with the new development, that the building could leak at the thousands of joints between the different pieces that would make up the structure.

For some, the stalled development is proof that it will be hard for modular construction — which is a cheaper alternative to regular construction — to become part of the mainstream.

Others are still hopeful that more projects will be constructed that way and point to modular towers that have been completed successfully in China and the United Kingdom.

“We’ll get there, I’m just not sure we’re there yet,” James Garrison, principal at Garrison Architects told the newspaper. “It’s like when you build an automobile. You know the fan belt has to clear the frame, the gas line has to have places to go—all of these things have to be integrated.” [WSJ] — Claire Moses


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Assembly OSM cofounders William and Christopher Sharples with an illustration of the building design (AOSM)
Modular construction firm founded by SHoP principals unveils first apartment
Modular construction firm founded by SHoP principals unveils first apartment
Quick turnaround times have luxury buyers considering modular as an alternative to traditional construction for grandiose homes. (iStock)
Modular construction works for luxury homes, too
Modular construction works for luxury homes, too
MaryAnne Gilmartin and a rendering of 335 Eighth Avenue (Getty, COOKFOX Architects)
MAG Partners to redevelop Chelsea corner
MAG Partners to redevelop Chelsea corner
Warren Buffet and a prototype of a MiTek and Danny Forster & Architecture building. (MiTek, Getty)
Warren Buffett bets on modular construction
Warren Buffett bets on modular construction
Mack-Cali Realty CEO Mahbod Nia and MaryAnne Gilmartin (Photos via Mack-Cali Realty)
Mack-Cali Realty names Mahbod Nia as CEO
Mack-Cali Realty names Mahbod Nia as CEO
 The Qualtrics Tower at 1201 2nd Avenue in Seattle with Hana Financial CEO Kim Jung-tai and Skanska USA CEO Richard Kennedy (Google Maps)
$700M Seattle office tower buy would be among largest Covid-era property deals
$700M Seattle office tower buy would be among largest Covid-era property deals
Mayor Bill de Blasio and (inset) the proposed development in Long Island City (Getty, YourLIC)
City ends talks with Gilmartin’s group to jointly rezone former Amazon site
City ends talks with Gilmartin’s group to jointly rezone former Amazon site
MaryAnne Gilmartin (Getty, iStock)
Rent-a-CEO: Inside Gilmartin’s short-term gig at Mack-Cali
Rent-a-CEO: Inside Gilmartin’s short-term gig at Mack-Cali
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...