Donny Deutsch stiffed Sotheby’s broker on commission: judge

But MSNBC host denies he went behind Sotheby agent's back to sell Hamptons home

New York /
Oct.October 30, 2014 09:01 AM

MSNBC host and former advertising titan Donny Deutsch allegedly tricked a real estate broker out of a $1.2 million commission by brokering the sale of his Hamptons home himself.

Deutsch’s lawyer allegedly brought in hedge fund manager Howard Marks to look at the Tyson Lane property, thereby going behind Sotheby’s International Realty broker Edward Petrie’s back and causing him to miss out on the 4 percent fee, according to court papers cited by the New York Post. The court is now ordering that Sotheby’s gets the $1.2 million commission after all.

“This court considers that and refusal to acknowledge [Petrie] as the broker to be marks of dishonesty and greed,” the judge wrote in an October 23 decision, according to the newspaper. “Both characteristics are particularly unbecoming when exhibited by those blessed with great wealth.”

Deutsch maintains that he never agreed on a 4 percent commission, according to the newspaper.

“There was no such agreement, neither verbal nor written, and internal Sotheby’s email communications confirm this. Mr. Deutsch will vigorously defend his position in court and is very confident this decision will be reversed on appeal,” a representative for Deutsch told the Post.

In 2012, contractors and architects who helped design his Upper East Side townhouse alleged that Deutsch stiffed them for work on the home[NYP] — Claire Moses


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Somerset Partners’ Keith Rubenstein and 8 East 62nd Street (Illustration by Kevin Cifuentes for The Real Deal with Getty Images, Realtor)
TRD Pro: These were Manhattan’s priciest home sales in September
TRD Pro: These were Manhattan’s priciest home sales in September
Miles Kwok with 781 Fifth Avenue (
Trustee alleges “shell game” over Chinese exile’s UES penthouse
Trustee alleges “shell game” over Chinese exile’s UES penthouse
Chris Poore (Sotheby’s International Realty)
Top BHS agent jumps back to Sotheby’s
Top BHS agent jumps back to Sotheby’s
Top to bottom: Daniela Sassoun, Daryl Eisenberg and Mark Mistovich (Sotheby's)
Top-performing Douglas Elliman agent pulls team to Sotheby’s International
Top-performing Douglas Elliman agent pulls team to Sotheby’s International
Clockwise from top left: Robert Reffkin, Corcoran; David Walker, Triplemint; Bess Friedman, Brown Harris Stevens; Scott Durkin, Douglas Elliman; Pam Liebman, Corcoran; Frederick Peters, Coldwell Banker Warburg
Resi royalty: Ranking Manhattan’s top residential brokerages of 2021
Resi royalty: Ranking Manhattan’s top residential brokerages of 2021
Realogy announces $300M stock buyback after strong quarter
Realogy announces $300M stock buyback after strong quarter
Realogy announces $300M stock buyback after strong quarter
Sotheby’s, Realogy make winning bid for Concierge Auctions
Sotheby’s, Realogy make winning bid for Concierge Auctions
Sotheby’s, Realogy make winning bid for Concierge Auctions
90 Jule Pond Drive (Sotheby’s International Realty)
Hamptons estate asking $145M under contract, may set record
Hamptons estate asking $145M under contract, may set record
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...