Landlords put spy cams in young tenant’s UWS pad: suit

Owners allegedly collected 70 videos of the woman engaged in private acts

TRD New York /
Nov.November 05, 2014 02:37 PM

If a rent-free apartment on the Upper West Side of Manhattan seems too good to be true, that’s because it is. A young student living in New York who got a rent-free deal is suing her landlords for allegedly playing “I spy” with her by installing illegal cameras in the bedroom and bathroom of her apartment.

Aksana Kuzmitskaya filed suit against her former employers and landlords Eli Kadoch and Michel Kadoe, who own and manage 7 West 82nd Street, in New York Supreme Court on Monday.

In 2013,  Kuzmitskaya was hired by 7 West 82nd Street LLC to maintain and clean apartments in the nine-unit brownstone building. She moved into her unit, #3B in December 2013 after Kadoe and Kadoch made multiple requests for her to do so, the suit alleges. They offered her room and board as part of her employee compensation. As landlords, Kadoch and Kadoe had the keys to her apartment.

Kadoch and Kadoe entered the apartment on numerous occasions,  Kuzmitskaya alleges in the suit. Over the course of roughly six months, the defendants gathered at least 70 videos of her engaging in private acts, according to the suit, which says that the landlords engaged in “intentional infringement on her privacy rights.” The landlords spied on Kuzmitskaya while she was either naked or in her underwear, using the bathroom, engaging in sexual acts and showering. The “high-powered” video cameras were concealed in “unsuspecting devices” in the unit’s bathroom, the suit alleges. The defendants allegedly maintained a live feed of the footage.

After she discovered the cameras, Kutzmitskaya called the police, who in turn launched a criminal investigation. Police seized the landlords’ surveillance devices, wireless remotes, laptops and other related equipment.

Kutzmitskaya quit working for the landlords immediately after discovering the cameras and moved out of the building in July 2014, according to court papers. She is suing for an undisclosed sum for loss of wages, compensatory and punitive damages as well as attorney fees.

Joseph Mure, Kuzmitskaya’s lawyer, was not immediately available for comment on Wednesday afternoon.

On October 31, a New York County grand jury indicted Kadoch on ten felony counts for the unlawful recordings. According to the court documents, some of the recordings show Kadoch repositioning the cameras in Kuzmitskaya’s apartment.

A LinkedIn profile of a woman with the same name indicates that Kuzmitskaya is from Belarus, is working toward becoming a computer programmer and earned a bachelor’s degree in 2010 from Hrodna State University in Belarus.

In 2009, Kadoe was hit with a $4.5 million lawsuit for illegally using a portion of his building at 7 West 82nd Street as a hotel. Back then, a neighbor alleged Kadoe housed noisy tourists in the building’s garden apartment and created an eyesore for neighbors after he installed a fence in the backyard.

Related Article

Community Housing Improvement Program director Jay Martin, RSA president Joseph Strasburg and Mayer Brown’s Andrew Pincus with the US Supreme Court (Credit: iStock and Wikipedia)

Behind real estate’s scramble to fight the new rent law in court

Speaker of the New York City Council Corey Johnson (Credit: Getty Images and iStock)

City Council approves package of 17 bills to strengthen tenant protections

Clockwise from top: Related chairman Steven Ross, Mactaggart Family & Partners CEO Philip Mactaggart, a rendering of 456 Greenwich Street, and Caspi Development's Joshua Caspi (Credit: Getty Images, Mactaggart, and MHA Westchester)

Developers of bankrupt Tribeca hotel project think Related might be colluding with their landlord

“If you love your children, leave the building”: Simon Baron accused of harassing tenant over $3.5M buyout

It may soon get easier to hit landlords with criminal harassment charges

City Council seeks to ramp up oversight of vacant property

Here’s how de Blasio will “take” buildings from bad landlords

Money for nothing: Landlords are accused of overcharging tenants for poor renovation work, but is state law to blame?