Investors in Scribner mansion sue seller after $22.5M deal

Oliver Bivins went ahead with deal without their knowledge or consent, suit states

New York /
Nov.November 14, 2014 05:46 PM

A week after the iconic Scribner mansion on the Upper East Side traded hands for $22.5 million, five investors who claim to have a stake in the property are suing the seller for allegedly doing the deal without their knowledge or consent.

The investors — Jedediah and Zachary Turner, Erik Schafer, Edward Kuhnel and Alex de Bie together with 39E67th LLC – are suing the seller Oliver Bivins II in New York Supreme Court. They claim that Bivins breached an agreement in which they were entitled to a 20 percent ownership stake.

They further claim that they didn’t know about the sale or give their consent, and are suing for $4.5 million plus interest and damages.

Bivins had owned the property — as well as an Upper East Side property at 808 Lexington Avenue and other buildings in Florida and the United Kingdom— since March 2011, when his mother Lorna passed away and left him her estate.

Under Bivins’ leadership, however, the buildings fell into disrepair, the plaintiffs allege.

The five investors paid off the defaulted mortgage on The 808 Lexington Avenue building, which was later transferred to Bivins’ father. In return, the plaintiffs were promised 20 percent ownership of the Scribner mansion.

In 2013, the plaintiffs agreed to a deal in which they would co-own the mansion with Bivins through an entity called 39E67th LLC. The title of the building, however, was never transferred to reflect the new ownership structure, the lawsuit alleges.

The 9,444-square-foot mansion had been in the same hands for more than 50 years before Bivins sold it earlier this month to an unidentified buyer, as The Real Deal reported. The house is currently split into four full-floor apartments, but a new buyer could turn it into a single-family home. A doctor’s office occupies the ground floor.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Carlton Hobbs with 60 East 93rd Street (Getty, Google Maps)
One of NYC’s widest townhouses sells for $53M
One of NYC’s widest townhouses sells for $53M
From left: Bert H. Dweck and Joe Sitt with 790 Madison Avenue (
Joe Sitt, Bert Dweck settle Madison Ave dispute with fashion house
Joe Sitt, Bert Dweck settle Madison Ave dispute with fashion house
Orbach Affordable Housing Solutions' Meyer Orbach and One East River Place (Orbach Housing, Google Maps)
Black Spruce, Orbach strike $1.8B NYC multifamily deal
Black Spruce, Orbach strike $1.8B NYC multifamily deal
790 Madison Avenue, Thor Equities CEO Joe Sitt and Bert Dweck (Google Maps, Thor and Premier Equities)
Fashion house: After 2 years and 2 lawsuits, Sitt and Dweck still haven’t paid
Fashion house: After 2 years and 2 lawsuits, Sitt and Dweck still haven’t paid
Gary Barnett along with renderings of 1637 First Avenue (Extell Development, iStock)
Extell lands $125M loan for UES resi project
Extell lands $125M loan for UES resi project
Jed H. Garfield and 510 East 89th Street (Leslie J. Garfield, Google Maps)
Townhouse guru Jed Garfield swaps Yorkville home for UWS condo
Townhouse guru Jed Garfield swaps Yorkville home for UWS condo
109 East 79th Street
17-foot ceilings help Legion condo snag priciest contract of the week
17-foot ceilings help Legion condo snag priciest contract of the week
Bernie Madoff’s UES penthouse hits market for third time since his arrest
Bernie Madoff’s UES penthouse hits market for third time since his arrest
Bernie Madoff’s UES penthouse hits market for third time since his arrest
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...