Naftali sues wealthy renters who refuse to leave penthouse

Developer claims couple's continued presence has caused $25M in construction delays

TRD New York /
Mar.March 19, 2015 01:50 PM

The Naftali Group sued a wealthy couple occupying one of its penthouses, claiming that the couple refused to leave after their lease expired and thus preventing the developer from proceeding with a condominium conversion.

Naftali bought the Shepherd House at 277 West 10th Street in the West Village in partnership with Starwood Capital last year for $68.2 million, with plans to convert the rental building to condos, and reduce the number of units from 145 to just 42, according to the New York Daily News.

David Moody, a mergers-and-acquisitions attorney, and Ellen Guilfoyle started renting the apartment in 2013 at $7,800 per month, but the rent eventually increased to $25,000 per month. Naftali served them with an early-termination notice last year, and their original lease expired in February, but allegedly, they are staying put. According to the suit, the couple has purchased a $4 million apartment nearby and does not want to leave until renovations are completed at The New Place.

The landlord also claims that the couple owes $120,000 in back rent, that their behavior has been “willful, malicious and unconscionable,” and that they have caused $25 million in construction delays. [NYDN] — Tess Hofmann


Related Articles

Miki Naftali and 1045 Madison Avenue (Credit: Getty Images, Google Maps)

Naftali accused of violating zoning laws at UES development

Developer Miki Naftali (Credit: Naftali Group and iStock)

Yacht Rock: Miki Naftali facing $725K lawsuit from boat broker

Gale Brewer proposes women’s jail at Lincoln Correctional Facility (Credit: Getty Images and iStock)

Gale Brewer wants to turn “prime, trophy real estate” into women’s jail

200 East 83rd Street and Miki Naftali (Credit: Google Maps) 

Naftali Group lands $176M for (another) Upper East side project

1039-1045 Madison Avenue and Miki Naftali (Credit: Google Maps)

Naftali lands $120M+ in financing for Upper East Side project

From left: 275 West 10th Street, 250 West 81st Street and 320 West 101st Street

These are some of the most notable resi sales in NYC this week

David Bistricer and 21 West 86th Street (Credit: Studio Scrivo, Google Maps)

Clipper Equity plans $204M conversion of UWS rental

200 East 83rd Street and Naftali Group's Miki Naftali (Credit: Naftali Group)

Naftali, Rockefeller are bringing a luxury condo tower to the UES