Developers eyeing legal challenge to 421a labor deal

Legal experts say the state is handing unprecedented power to the private sector

TRD New York /
Jul.July 02, 2015 09:01 AM

In response to a compromise on 421a that requires the Real Estate Board of New York and labor unions to reach a deal on wages by January 2016, some developers are considering taking legal action against the government.

Real estate insiders are predicting court actions, according to Crain’s. Lawsuits could challenge the fact that an important aspect of the law – the wage requirement for construction workers on buildings over 15 units that are receiving the tax abatement – has been left in the hands of the private sector.

During negotiations over the renewal of 421a, Mayor Bill de Blasio argued that a prevailing wage requirement would slow the construction of affordable housing, while Governor Andrew Cuomo made the prevailing wage requirement a top priority.

“It’s unusual for government to delegate authority to the private sector,” said Randy Mastro, a partner at Gibson Dunn & Crutcher who has sued the state and local governments many times. “I’m not aware of New York state doing that ever before.”

Many developers are hesitant to make plans to build rentals until they can be sure that 421a will exist past January of next year. [Crain’s] — Tess Hofmann

Related Articles

The issue came to light after some owners realized they were incorrectly billed in June (Credit: iStock)

“A big, big, big success,” NYC Finance Department says of new system that overcharged building owners on property tax

With the elimination of vacancy decontrol, landlords can't deregulate units in buildings receiving 421a until the tax break expires (Credit: iStock)

Collateral damage? Real estate sounds alarm on rent regs’ impact on condos, 421a

100 Riverside Boulevard is one property whose tax abatements are ending

With 421a ending, more condo owners are selling their apartments

Brooklyn developer overcharged tenants by more than $1M at new 421a building: lawsuit

For developers who love the old 421a, stalled construction sites are ripe for the picking

New York has lost more than 400K affordable apartments since 2005: comptroller’s report

When 421a was in limbo, developers turned to this tax exemption

Sheldon Silver found guilty, again