Supreme Court ruling puts NYC affordable housing plan in peril

Ruling could leave the city policy open to discrimination suits

New York /
Jul.July 14, 2015 05:45 PM

A recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling that reinterprets the Fair Housing Act could threaten New York City’s longtime practice of building new affordable housing units in low-income and minority neighborhoods.

The high court’s June 25 decision, written by Justice Anthony Kennedy, would require anyone challenging an affordable housing policy as a violation of the Fair Housing Act to prove only that the policy itself is discriminatory, rather than prove it intentionally violated the rights of the people covered under the act.

The ruling could present a major obstacle to Mayor Bill de Blasio’s drive to construct 80,000 new affordable housing units within the next decade, according to experts in housing law, Crain’s reported.

The [de Blasio] administration is definitely going to have to think through the implications of all its housing policies,” Kenneth Fisher, a former City Council member and land-use attorney at Cozen O’Connor, told Crain’s. “They will need to be able to explain to the Department of Justice and [the Department of Housing and Urban Development] why their policies are furthering integration—and not segregation.”

New York City for a long time has concentrated housing subsidies on affordable housing construction in lower-income neighborhoods with large populations of minority residents. Land costs in those areas are substantially lower than in more affluent locales such as Manhattan or Brooklyn, so the subsidies help pay for more housing units.

But the high court’s ruling makes this policy vulnerable to legal challenges under the premise that focusing subsidies on lower-income areas increases economic and racial segregation, even if this is not the policy’s intent. — TRD


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Assemblyman N. Nick Perry and Sen. Brian Kavanagh (Getty, iStock, NY State Assembly)
New bill would force co-op boards to explain rejections
New bill would force co-op boards to explain rejections
The state has opened 52 more investigations into potential fair-housing law violations tied to the Newsday report (iStock)
Agents named in discrimination exposé face discipline from state
Agents named in discrimination exposé face discipline from state
President Trump (Getty, iStock)
Trump repeals HUD rule in bid to win over the ‘burbs
Trump repeals HUD rule in bid to win over the ‘burbs
34-08 30th Street (Credit: Google Maps)
Lawsuit accuses Astoria landlord, super of turning away blacks
Lawsuit accuses Astoria landlord, super of turning away blacks
Mayor Bill de Blasio (Credit: Getty Images)
De Blasio to test brokers, owners for housing discrimination
De Blasio to test brokers, owners for housing discrimination
The Sand Castle apartment complex at 7-11 Seagirt Ave in Far Rockaway (Credit: Google Maps)
Queens landlords settle record $1M discrimination case
Queens landlords settle record $1M discrimination case
This way to the beach: Supreme Court won’t hear billionaire’s appeal to close California beach path
This way to the beach: Supreme Court won’t hear billionaire’s appeal to close California beach path
This way to the beach: Supreme Court won’t hear billionaire’s appeal to close California beach path
Landlords are discriminating against porn stars. Is it legal?
Landlords are discriminating against porn stars. Is it legal?
Landlords are discriminating against porn stars. Is it legal?
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...