Aby Rosen sues owner of Peter Elliot Blue boutique

RFR claims tenant Elliot Rabin owes $1.3M in rent at 150 E. 72nd St.

TRD New York /
Aug.August 27, 2015 08:00 AM

UPDATED: Aug. 27, 5:32 p.m.: Upper East Side retailer Elliot Rabin is facing another lawsuit over his much-desired retail space at 150 East 72nd Street.

Landlord Aby Rosen’s RFR Holdings filed a lawsuit accusing Rabin, the owner of clothing boutique Peter Elliot Blue, of failing to pay $118,000 in rent for the months of April and May. In May, RFR told Rabin he was in rent default, but the bill remains unsettled, according to the lawsuit, which was filed Aug. 25.

According to the suit, RFR is seeking $1.3 million – an amount RFR claims it can collect in the event of a rent default.

Last year, Rabin — whose store was described by the New York Times as an “Upper East Side temple of navy blazers and sherbert-colored sweaters” — was slammed with another suit by former landlord Harry Macklowe’s Macklowe Properties. At that time, Macklowe alleged Rabin owed $100,000 in unpaid rent plus interest.

In a $6 million countersuit, Rabin said Macklowe was trying to push him out of the retail space before his lease ended to make way for a higher-paying tenant.

Macklowe paid $70 million for the entire building in 2011, and subsequently converted the rental apartments into high-end condos.

By Rabin’s account, Macklowe’s workmen cause damage to his store, destroyed his stockroom and turned off the air conditioning and heat. At one point in 2013, Macklowe warned Rabin, “Don’t forget I am Goliath,” to which Rabin replied, “You just met David,” according to last year’s countersuit.

In March 2014, Macklowe sold the retail space at the base of his condominium to RFR for nearly $20 million. The retail spread includes 4,000-square-feet of space plus 900 square feet on a basement level.

A month after RFR’s acquisition, the developer offered Rabin a new lease for the ground floor and basement with annual rent of $1.1 million and a $275,000 security deposit, according to the suit.

“Aby Rosen is a very tough, but fair businessman. It is not his fault that all of this occurred,” Rabin told TRD on Thursday.

Rabin told TRD that after Rosen bought the retail space, he allowed the boutique to stay. But the store, which previously occupied part of the space, would need to take over the entire spread.

Rabin said he opted to stay, and Rosen subsequently offered him nine months’ worth of free rent and a “substantial” construction allowance to build out the larger store. “I made a tactical error in not using a contractor familiar with Macklowe or Rosen,” he said, describing construction-related delays that followed.

“[Rosen] warned me, ‘I don’t think you can handle the rent,’” Rabin recalled. Asked why he agreed to take the larger space, Rabin said: “Because I have a dream.”

Rabin said he’s looking for a financial partner to take advantage of the prime retail space he’s now occupying. “We’re sitting on gold and we’re mining silver,” he said.


Related Articles

Book Culture at 450 Columbus Avenue (Credit: Google Maps)

Upper West Side bookstore closes amid accusations of fraud

Firefighters work to extinguish a fire as a building burns after an explosion on 2nd Avenue in March 26, 2015 (Credit: Getty Images)

$24K in rent set in motion the fatal 2015 East Village blast. Prison now looms for the landlord and contractors

Ex-Barneys CEO Daniella Vitale (Credit: Getty Images, Google Maps)

Barneys’ lights still on, but workers left in dark

Harry and Linda Macklowe (Credit: Getty Images, iStock)

The Macklowes’ massive art collection nears auction

Heritage Equity Partners Toby Moskovits and Michael Lichtenstein

Lawsuit: Toby Moskovits, Michael Lichtenstein owe investor $3M

250 Fort Washington Ave and 310 Convent Avenue with Housing Rights Initiative’s Aaron Carr (Credit: iStock, Facebook, Google Maps)

Two more rent-overcharge lawsuits get class-action status

1074 Eastern Parkway in Brooklyn (Credit: Google Maps)

Crown Heights tenants sue infamous landlord for rent overcharges

Rent overcharge claims against landlords are on the rise (Credit: iStock)

Rent overcharge cases pile up