JD Carlisle allegedly broke 160 Madison Ave. commercial condo promise

Former property owner sues to take control of the unit, wants $8 million in damages

New York /
Sep.September 01, 2015 02:15 PM

Sometimes getting it in writing isn’t enough.

J.D. Carlisle allegedly promised the former owner of 160 Madison Avenue a commercial condominium in the new 42-story tower it was building on the site, but failed to deliver the goods, a new lawsuit claims.

John Rapp, a managing member of 168 Madison Avenue LLC, filed suit Tuesday in New York State Supreme Court, claiming that the commercial condo in the new 319-unit rental building was “a material part of the purchase price and consideration.” The contract spelled out the details: the commercial unit was to be 3,500 square feet, with 35 feet of Frontage On Madison Avenue, according to the suit.

J.D. Carlisle bought the property in 2012, paying $12 million. According the lawsuit, the commercial condo is worth $8 million or more. The former owner is seeking a court order to force J.D. Carlisle to provide the unit, along with damages to exceed $8 million.

A copy of the contract of sale was filed as Exhibit A in the case, but was apparently later retracted.

A representative from J.D. Carlisle with knowledge of the case wasn’t available to comment. John Rapp couldn’t be reached, and attorneys representing 168 Madison Avenue LLC declined to comment.

 
 

Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
141 East 89th Street, 250 East 73rd Street and 1594 3rd Avenue (Google Maps, LoopNet)
City landlord fears his mother gifted him $50M tax liability
City landlord fears his mother gifted him $50M tax liability
Valerie Dillon and Arthur Becker with 465 Washington
After battle with Becker, gallery owner sells Tribeca pad
After battle with Becker, gallery owner sells Tribeca pad
Pastor Gregory Fryer and the Immanuel Lutheran Church at 120 and 122 East 88th Street (Getty Images, Immanuel NYC, Jim.henderson, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons)
Thou Shalt Not Sell: Lutheran group sues to stop church’s deals
Thou Shalt Not Sell: Lutheran group sues to stop church’s deals
212 Fifth Avenue, Thor's Joseph Sitt and Madison Equities CEO Robert Gladstone (Google Maps, Thor, Studio Scrivo)
Thor sues insurer over Bob Gladstone’s alleged theft from 212 Fifth
Thor sues insurer over Bob Gladstone’s alleged theft from 212 Fifth
The door at 553 West 30th Street, Related's Stephen Ross and 15 Hudson Yards (Getty, Google Maps)
Judge rejects “poor door” lawsuit at Related’s 15 Hudson Yards
Judge rejects “poor door” lawsuit at Related’s 15 Hudson Yards
Miki Naftali with 215 West 84th Street (Getty, Corcoran)
Naftali takes hit in battle with UWS holdout
Naftali takes hit in battle with UWS holdout
Ascent Development’s Tien Vominh and Modern Spaces' Eric Benaim with 45-30 Davis Street (LinkedIn, Modern Spaces, Marvel Architects)
Modern Spaces sues developer over LIC exclusivity agreement
Modern Spaces sues developer over LIC exclusivity agreement
From left: Jeff Goldberg, CEO of Fairstead, and Will Blodgett, Founder of Tredway (Getty Images, Fairstead)
Fairstead fires back, alleges Blodgett threatened to go “torched earth”
Fairstead fires back, alleges Blodgett threatened to go “torched earth”
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...