Is the S&P 500 a better investment than Manhattan condos?

CityRealty analysis compares prices at 100 luxury condo buildings to index fund

TRD New York /
Nov.November 05, 2015 06:05 PM

While Manhattan luxury condos have gained a reputation as a preferred store of wealth for super-rich investors the world over, those well-off Russian oligarchs and Chinese industrialists may have been better off investing in a boring old index fund instead.

Real estate analysts at CityRealty, curious how the top end of the city’s condo market fared against less glamorous investments, recently compiled the average price per square foot across a collection of 100 prominent Manhattan condo buildings.

They found that the value of those condos rose 55 percent in the past decade, from an average of $1,530 per square foot in 2005 to $2,371 per square foot this year. While that was good for a compound annual growth rate of 4.5 percent, it was no match for the S&P 500 – which had a 5.4 percent annual growth rate over the same period, according to Bloomberg.

Still, that doesn’t mean the likes of Bill Ackman and Ken Griffin should have bought index funds instead; as Bloomberg notes, the analysis makes for an interesting but imperfect comparison.

There’s no simple way, for example, to by and sell shares in the collection of 100 buildings analyzed by CityRealty, and the condo data is based on a limited number of transactions that have skewed higher thanks to the trend toward increasingly expensive apartments.

And then there’s the fact that, if you buy a $100 million apartment as an investment, you’re also able to live in it. That helps.

Meanwhile, none other than Donald Trump recently fell victim to a similar analysis by the Washington Post. [Bloomberg]Rey Mashayekhi

Related Articles

Clockwise from left: John D. Rockefeller, Izzy Englander, Steven Mnuchin, David Koch, Jacqueline Bouvier, and William Zeckendorf (Credit: Getty Images and StreetEasy)

For 15 years, David Koch lived at the world’s “richest building”

255 West 11th Street with Liv Tyler and 49 East 67th Street  with Thomas and Ann Unterberg (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

Here’s what sold in NYC’s luxury home market last week

Amenity insanity in LA luxe condo market

Amenity insanity in LA luxe condo market

110 Central Park South and Aleksandra Melnichenko (Credit: Google Maps and Getty Images)

Who’s buying what? Here are our top luxe resi sales

Lee Radziwill and her home at 160 East 72nd Street (Credit: Getty Images, Brown Harris Stevens)

Longtime home of Lee Radziwill, sister to Jackie O., sells for $4M

993 Fifth Avenue and Gilbert Harrison (Credit: Google Maps and GLC)

Retail exec sells Fifth Avenue co-op to Chanel heir for $19M

Clockwise from left: 240 Riverside Boulevar with  Charles Zegar, 111 Murray Street, and 220 Central Park South (Credit: Google Maps, Getty Images, and CityRealty)

Here are some of the Big Apple’s recent luxury resi buys

Clockwise from left: 91 Leonard Street, 141 West 11th Street, 520 Park Avenue and 115 Central Park West (Credit: StreetEasy, Google Maps)

These are the latest, greatest residential sales in NYC