Brokerage claims Starwood, MHP cut it out of $72M hotel site deal

Deborah A. Schwartz Real Estate sues for $1.8M over 1414 Sixth Avenue

New York /
Dec.December 22, 2015 05:03 PM

Brokerage Deborah A. Schwartz Real Estate is suing Starwood Capital and Murray Hill Properties, alleging it was cut out of a $72 million deal between the two commercial giants despite having done all the legwork on it.

Deborah A. Schwartz Real Estate (DAS) claims that in 2010, it provided Starwood with “an entire universe of available information” about 1414 Sixth Avenue, an 18-story commercial building at West 58th Street owned by MHP. After receiving information on the property, Starwood allegedly told DAS that it was no longer interested in buying it.

DAS alleges that MHP then went behind its back and hired a second broker, Ivan Hakimian, who allegedly approached Starwood CEO Barry Sternlicht about a potential deal. In February 2011, Starwood bought the property for $72 million, and eventually developed a 229-key hotel known as 1 Hotel Central Park on it.

MHP and Hakimian, the lawsuit claims, arranged to strike one commission agreement with Itzhaki Properties (Hakimian’s former employer, now known as EPIC Commercial Realty), for a reduced rate of $360,000, and arranged a “secret second commission” of $300,000 to be paid directly to Hakimian.

The suit alleges that the defendants “defrauded not one, but two, brokers in connection with the same transaction,” since Itzhaki didn’t know it was getting a lower commission.

Hakimian, who isn’t named as a defendant in the suit, couldn’t be reached for comment, nor could representatives for Starwood and MHP. A representative for EPIC declined to comment, as did Matthew Press, an attorney for DAS.

As a result of MHP and Starwood’s actions, the lawsuit claims, DAS lost out on a commission of $1.8 million, and the brokerage is seeking damages of that amount, plus interest.

DAS, headed by Deborah Schwartz and Alan Bollinger, has filed similar claims against clients in the past. In 2008, the brokerage sued Rocky Mount Baptist Church for allegedly failing to pay a $192,000 commission after DAS found a buyer for the church’s property. The case was settled in 2012, but details of the settlement weren’t immediately available. It appears that of the more than a dozen civil cases filed in New York courts involving the brokerage or its principals — as both plaintiff and defendant — only the Starwood case is active.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Kevin Lalezarian and 567 Third Avenue (Google Maps)
Lalezarian has big plans in Murray Hill
Lalezarian has big plans in Murray Hill
123 East 35th Street (Streeteasy)
Listed for first time in 40 years, Murray Hill mansion asks $33M
Listed for first time in 40 years, Murray Hill mansion asks $33M
99 Park Avenue, CardWorks' Don Berman and AKAM president Michael Rogoff (Google Maps, CardWorks, AKAM)
Global Holdings signs three new tenants at 99 Park
Global Holdings signs three new tenants at 99 Park
Barry Sternlicht, co-founder, chairman, and CEO of Starwood Capital Group (Starwood Capital Group, LoopNet, iStock/Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
Extended-stay hotels a hot commodity for investors
Extended-stay hotels a hot commodity for investors
From left: Stephen Schwarzman, chairman, Blackstone; Barry Sternlicht, chief executive officer, Starwood Capital Group (Getty Images, Brookfield Asset Management/Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal)
Blackstone, Starwood to pay $1.5B for WoodSpring Suites properties
Blackstone, Starwood to pay $1.5B for WoodSpring Suites properties
Bruce Eichner and the Community Church of New York at 40 East 35th Street (Google Maps)
Eichner to buy cash-strapped Midtown church for $70M, eyeing condo project
Eichner to buy cash-strapped Midtown church for $70M, eyeing condo project
Starwood Property Trust's Barry Sternlicht (Getty, iStock)
“Good luck finding people”: Sternlicht warns of labor shortage for infrastructure bill
“Good luck finding people”: Sternlicht warns of labor shortage for infrastructure bill
Sam Zell (left) and Barry Sternlicht (Photos by Studio Scrivo and Emily Assiran)
Battle of Monmouth: Zell and Sternlicht’s $2B struggle over warehouse REIT
Battle of Monmouth: Zell and Sternlicht’s $2B struggle over warehouse REIT
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...