BKR’s Kanarek sues Alchemy, Savills Studley over lost commissions

Broker seeking commissions and millions in damages over two UES properties

Jan.January 13, 2016 04:56 PM

Commercial broker Brian Kanarek is suing Alchemy Properties, Savills Studley and Studley broker David Carlos, accusing them of cutting him out of a commission on two potential Alchemy deals on the Upper East Side.

Kanarek, principal at BKR Partners, claims he approached Alchemy in Fall 2013 and offered to arrange for the firm to buy the Temple Shaaray Tefila synagogue building at 250 East 79th Street on the Upper East Side as well as the air rights associated with the property, according to the complaint.

Alchemy retained his services as the broker on the deal, Kanarek’s suit, filed in New York State Supreme Court on Tuesday, alleges. He made a series of offers to the synagogue on Alchemy’s behalf — including one on Dec. 11, 2013 for $35 million, the suit claims.

Kanarek then offered to represent Alchemy on another potential deal in the area, the acquisition of a rental building at 242-244 East 79th Street, owned by the Emmes Group of Companies. Through Kanarek, Alchemy submitted a $35 million offer in March 2014 to buy the property, the suit states.

Temple Shaaray Tefila then hired its own broker, the suit claims: David Carlos of Savills Studley. Kanarek and Carlos then struck an agreement to split any possible commission from the synagogue deal.

But Carlos went to Alchemy and poisoned the relationship between Kanarek and the developer, the complaint alleges.

“Mr. Carlos spoke directly with [Kenneth] Horn at Alchemy and willfully, maliciously, and falsely accused Mr. Kanarek of trying to put an alternate deal together involving [250 East 79th Street] with a different buyer that was at cross purposes with any purchase of the [the property] by Alchemy,” the complaint states. This, Kanarek alleges, caused him to lose Alchemy’s business.

Kanerek is seeking a two percent commission on both deals, should they close, as well as several million dollars in damages.

A spokesperson for Savills Studley declined to comment on the suit. Alchemy, which is converting the top of the Woolworth Building into luxury condominiums, didn’t immediately return a request for comment.

Related Articles

Empire State Realty Trust’s CEO Tony Malkin at last year's MIPIM conference in New York (Credit: Getty Images)

MIPIM postponed until June as coronavirus spreads

Fears of coronavirus have led some of the world’s most prominent commercial real estate companies to pull out of the MIPIM conference in Cannes, France. (Credit: Getty Images, iStock)

Coronavirus exodus: CRE bigwigs ditch MIPIM

Clockwise from left: JLL's Michele Mahl, Savills' Peter Hennessy, Eastdil Secured's Will Silverman, Christie’s Brian Meier, Nest Seekers' Mike Fabbri and Compass' Charlie Attias 

These were the biggest broker comings and goings of 2019

Savills vice chairman Peter Hennessy

Peter Hennessy heading to Savills

From left: London, Shanghai and Paris

Ed Sheeran builds a village, Notre Dame restoration halted: Global property

Forget San Francisco… New York is now the world’s best tech city: Savills

Forget San Francisco… New York is now the world’s best tech city: Savills

At the desk of: Joel Breitkopf

At the desk of: Joel Breitkopf

Alchemy, Korean firm pay $158M for UWS church site

Alchemy, Korean firm pay $158M for UWS church site