Relocating MSG would cost $5B: Think tank

Advocates have pushed for the move as part of the Penn Station redevelopment

TRD New York /
Apr.April 26, 2016 10:42 AM

Moving Madison Square Garden a few blocks away to make for the redeveloped, above-ground Penn Station may seem romantic, but it’ll also be very, very costly, according to new research.

The price tag for relocating the 1960s-era arena would run as high as $5 billion, according to a study by the Rudin Center for Transportation Policy and Management, the Commercial Observer reported.

The report also cited the long timeframe and logistical headaches involved in any move. Advocates of the idea “are pursuing a dream that is unlikely to ever be fulfilled,” the Center’s Mitchell Moss told the Observer. The notion of an above-ground Penn Station, he told the publication, “is another example of architects run wild.”

In 2013, the New York City Council renewed the Garden’s special permit – similar to a lease – for only 10 years, to allow for the possibility that it be relocated.

Requests for proposals to redevelop Penn Station, the James A. Farley Post Office or both together were due on Friday.

At least 10 developers were reportedly interested in bidding on the project, including Extell Development, Silverstein Properties, Tishman Speyer, JDS Development Group and Brookfield Property Partners, along with Vornado Realty Trust and Related Companies, whom Gov. Andrew Cuomo removed from the project in January, after years of foot-dragging.

Cuomo announced a $3 billion plan to redevelop the area that month, with design-build work expected to be completed within three years. [CO]Ariel Stulberg

Related Articles


Vornado wants to clean up “crack alley” around One Penn Plaza

This month in real estate history

Madison Square Garden Co. is accusing the mayor of Inglewood of “outrageous, fraudulent conduct”

City and MSG look like they’re headed toward showdown over stadium relocation

Puma moving Garment District office and showroom to Penn Station area

Cuomo wants the state to take control of land surrounding Penn Station

Let’s say Elon Musk’s Hyperloop actually happens. Here’s where it could go in NYC

Plan scrapped for new tunnel between Penn Station and Jersey