The judges who rule over real estate: Judge Marcy Friedman

Part IV in TRD's overview of the New York property law bench

New York /
Apr.April 28, 2016 10:30 AM

From the April issue: This month, The Real Deal profiled six of the nine judges on the Supreme Court’s Commercial Division bench — focusing on those who have overseen some of the city’s biggest real estate cases in the last few years. This is Part IV.

Although Justice Marcy Friedman is just shy of four years in the Commercial Division, she has more experience overseeing real estate cases than almost anyone on the bench.

Appointed as a housing court judge in 1991, Friedman developed a reputation as a fervent defender of tenant rights. She joined the Supreme Court in 2000, hearing, among other things, torts and commercial cases, including many in real estate.

In 2010, Friedman issued a crucial rent-stabilization decision.

The case involved a move by Laurence Gluck’s Stellar Management to deregulate units at its giant 1,331-unit Complex Independence Plaza North in Tribeca while also receiving the J-51 tax abatement. Stellar notified the city that it wanted to stop receiving the tax abatement so that it could begin destabilizing rent-regulated apartments. But the government mistakenly kept the benefits going for two years and tenants argued that their units had therefore been illegally destabilized. Friedman decided that the tenants were indeed entitled to rent-stabilization.

But just two years later, the Appellate Court knocked Friedman’s ruling down. Gluck also paid back the J-51 benefits he received.

Bailey, who represents both tenants and landlords, described Friedman as “very, very pro-tenant” While She Was A Housing Court judge but said that changed once she joined the Supreme Court. “She got rid of her bias completely,” he said.

Since joining the Commercial Division, Friedman has heard a number of residential mortgage-backed securities cases in which RMBS investors who saw their money evaporate during the financial crisis filed claims against banks, alleging that the financial institutions had not properly outlined the risks in offering materials.

While Friedman has thrown out some RMBS cases, she’s also notably rejected defendants’ attempts to dismiss these cases — like when New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman sued CreditSuisse alleging RMBS fraud totaling $10 billion. CreditSuisse argued that it was too late to sue, but Friedman begged to differ and the case is still ongoing.

In 2013, the New York Supreme Court issued an order to have all future RMBS cases alleging wrongdoing by the issuer sent to Friedman.

Several attorneys described Friedman as a master diplomat, known for aggressively urging parties to settle out of court.

“Litigation is a very expensive vehicle to resolve differences,” said real estate attorney Gary Wachtel. “She tries to get attorneys to see the forest through the trees in an effort to settle cases.”

Bailey said Friedman’s “intelligence and analytical thinking” helps “in getting cases resolved and helps her ferret out frivolous claims.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Marble Ridge Capital LP's Dan Kamensky and Neiman Marcus at Hudson Yards in New York (Getty; Jewish National Fund)

Hedge fund manager arrested for fraud in Neiman Marcus bankruptcy

Hedge fund manager arrested for fraud in Neiman Marcus bankruptcy
Riza Aziz and (clockwise from left: 912 Hillcrest Road in Beverly Hills, Park Laurel in Manhattan and 2 Lygon Place in London (Getty, Google Maps, Realtor)

“Wolf of Wall Street” producer to forfeit $60M in 1MDB probe settlement

“Wolf of Wall Street” producer to forfeit $60M in 1MDB probe settlement
731 Lexington Avenue (Google Maps)

Former Turner Construction exec pleads guilty in bribery scheme

Former Turner Construction exec pleads guilty in bribery scheme
Savraj Gata-Aura

Bar Works Ponzi schemer sentenced to prison

Bar Works Ponzi schemer sentenced to prison
60 Riverside Boulevard and (inset) the island of Nauru (Google Maps)

UWS condo caught up in bribery scandal tied to world’s smallest republic

UWS condo caught up in bribery scandal tied to world’s smallest republic
Robert Durst appears in court for during opening statements in his murder trial on March 4, 2020 in Los Angeles (Photo by Etienne Laurent -Pool/Getty Images)

Robert Durst murder trial could be suspended as LA courts shutter over coronavirus

Robert Durst murder trial could be suspended as LA courts shutter over coronavirus
Larkin Plaza (Credit: Rendering courtesy of SLCE Architects)

RXR project among developments caught up in alleged Gambino mob scheme

RXR project among developments caught up in alleged Gambino mob scheme
Michael Shah (Credit: iStock)

Manhattan DA drops charges against developer Michael Shah

Manhattan DA drops charges against developer Michael Shah
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...