That Related-funded Hudson Yards economic report? Here are 3 big questions it doesn’t answer

Study claims megadevelopment will contribute $18.9B annually to NYC, more than Iceland's GDP

TRD New York /
May.May 03, 2016 07:00 AM

A new study claims Related Companies’ massive Hudson Yards project will contribute $25.6 billion to New York’s gross domestic product during construction, and another $18.9 billion annually after completion. That’s bigger than the GDP of Iceland!

But the report, commissioned by Related, authored by consultancy Appleseed and published Monday under the title “An Investment That’s Paying Off,” leaves a number of questions left unanswered. Here are three of the biggest:

1. No vacancy: The report claims that once completed, Hudson Yards will generate (directly and indirectly) more than $42.1 billion in annual output. Of that, $18.9 billion will be a net contribution to GDP (i.e. Hudson Yards’ output minus its input costs). But that’s based on the assumption that its office vacancy rate will be merely 5 percent. Is that realistic?

Midtown’s office availability rate stood at 10.6 percent in the first quarter, according to Colliers International, and signs point to a softening market. Adding millions of square feet of office space at Hudson Yards should push up vacancy rates in the medium run. And historically, most giant office projects like the Empire State Building or the World Trade Center struggled with high vacancy rates after completion. Besides, if there is near-limitless demand for expensive new office space, why is Silverstein Properties struggling to fill 2 World Trade Center?

Related’s Michael Samuelian argues that Hudson Yards is simply a better product, and that the fact that its first two office towers are virtually leased up means subsequent towers will likely also be fully leased. That’s possible, but there is no guarantee that will happen, and assuming a 5 percent vacancy rate in the face of far less rosy real-world numbers seems suspect.

2. Moving Peter to pay Paul: Even if all Hudson Yards towers are fully leased, many of those tenants have come and will continue to come from Midtown. What is $42.1 billion in output worth if it’s merely shifted over from other parts of the city? If businesses that directly and indirectly generate $42.1 billion worth of annual output leave Midtown and relocate to Hudson Yards, for example, the net benefit to the city is… $0.

The report’s authors recognize this and concede that Hudson Yard’s net benefit to the city will be smaller than $42.1 billion at first. Still, given the demand for new space amid Manhattan’s aging office stock, Appleseed’s president Hugh O’Neil argued that “it doesn’t take long before all that office space becomes totally a net addition to city’s economy.” And Samuelian pointed to a 2013 report by the Independent Budget Office, which argued that New York will need to add 52 million square feet of office space by 2040 to meet demand.

The logic holds that in the long run, having more high-quality office space makes it more likely that companies move to New York and existing ones stay. But how long of a run are we talking? Is it really likely that Hudson Yards will add much to the city’s output in its first decade after completion? The report doesn’t address these concerns.

3.  Opportunity cost: The report claims that Hudson Yards will contribute $1.78 billion to the MTA’s coffers during construction through ground lease payments and air rights purchases, and another $89 million annually after completion. But it’s not as if the MTA’s only choice was between leasing the land to Related et al. and letting it sit empty and making no money from it. The MTA could have done other things with the land (though it’s also true that no one else put forth a viable alternative). To truly gauge Hudson Yards’ benefit to the MTA, one would need to subtract the opportunity cost of not pursuing alternative uses.

Appleseed’s generally well-researched report makes the case that spending all that money on Hudson Yards will have a big economic impact – which should be beyond dispute.

But it doesn’t attempt to answer the truly important question: what exactly the development’s net economic benefit to the city will be one year, five years or 10 years after completion? Casual readers may get the impression that it does, however. Deputy Mayor Alicia Glen certainly appears to have understood it that way, saying in a statement that the report is a “clear affirmation that the city’s infrastructure investment was a wise one.”


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
(Image by Wolfgang & Hite via Dezeen)

Hudson Yards megadevelopment inspires a new line of sex toys

Hudson Yards megadevelopment inspires a new line of sex toys
Related's Jamar Adams and Steve Ross with 14-06 Gateway Boulevard (Credit: Getty Images and Google Maps)

Related is the latest developer to target the Rockaways

Related is the latest developer to target the Rockaways
The Observation Deck at Hudson Yards (Credit: Adam Pogoff)

Views from 1,100 feet: A tour of Related’s “the edge,” the tallest outdoor observation deck in the Western Hemisphere

Views from 1,100 feet: A tour of Related’s “the edge,” the tallest outdoor observation deck in the Western Hemisphere
Neiman Marcus at Hudson Yards and Geoffroy van Raemdonck (Getty)

Neiman Marcus exits bankruptcy $4B lighter

Neiman Marcus exits bankruptcy $4B lighter
Barclays CEO Jes Staley and Hudson Yards (Getty)

Barclays eyes big move to Hudson Yards

Barclays eyes big move to Hudson Yards
President Donald Trump and Joseph Biden (Getty, iStock)

Real estate donors backing Biden over Trump

Real estate donors backing Biden over Trump
Tel Aviv Stock Exchange bull (Wikimedia Commons)

NYC developers face downgrades on Israeli bond market

NYC developers face downgrades on Israeli bond market
Related chairman Stephen Ross with President Donald Trump and Hudson Yards (Photos via Getty Images)

Stephen Ross dishes on Trump, NYC mayoral race

Stephen Ross dishes on Trump, NYC mayoral race
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...