Shelter Island mansion asks $32M

That’s more than three times the island’s current sales record

TRD New York /
Jul.July 23, 2016 12:00 PM

One of Shelter Island’s best waterfront estates is poised to set a record for the idyllic isle. The 4.8-acre property has hit the market asking $32 million.

The current single-family sales record on Shelter Island belongs to a 5,100-square-foot house that sold for $9.5 million in 2014, according to the Wall Street Journal.

Owed by Dick Tarlow — a retired advertising-agency executive — this 7,000-square-foot, Queen Anne Victorian-style home was built around 1890 and has seven bedrooms and six bathrooms.

 

It has nine wood-burning fireplaces and wraparound porches, along with a tennis court, basketball court, pool, 80-foot dock and a boathouse. There is also a windmill on the property that has been converted into a guesthouse.

The price “is unheard of for Shelter Island,” Beate Moore of Sotheby’s International Realty told the Journal. “But we’re not worried about it, because it’s a world-class property.” [WSJ]Christopher Cameron


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Hamptons Cheat Sheet: Local home sales slow in September, Shelter Island compound lists for $14.2M … & more

Hamptons Cheat Sheet: Local home sales slow in September, Shelter Island compound lists for $14.2M … & more

Hamptons Cheat Sheet: Local home sales slow in September, Shelter Island compound lists for $14.2M … & more
Hamptons Cheat Sheet: Shelter Island homeowners sue over rental rules, Water Mill spec mansion lists for $32M … & more

Hamptons Cheat Sheet: Shelter Island homeowners sue over rental rules, Water Mill spec mansion lists for $32M … & more

Hamptons Cheat Sheet: Shelter Island homeowners sue over rental rules, Water Mill spec mansion lists for $32M … & more
Shelter Island property owners call new rental rules “devastating”

Shelter Island property owners call new rental rules “devastating”

Shelter Island property owners call new rental rules “devastating”
Hamptons Cheat Sheet: Good news and bad news in Q2 resi sales report, Stella McCartney pulls rental listing after being outed as owner … & more

Hamptons Cheat Sheet: Good news and bad news in Q2 resi sales report, Stella McCartney pulls rental listing after being outed as owner … & more

Hamptons Cheat Sheet: Good news and bad news in Q2 resi sales report, Stella McCartney pulls rental listing after being outed as owner … & more
Gardiners Bay Drive on Shelter Island

Hedge fund millionaire worms out of $400K Shelter Island landscaping bill on technicality

Hedge fund millionaire worms out of $400K Shelter Island landscaping bill on technicality
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...