Landmark Montauk “Shingle Style” house hits the market for $18.5M

TRD New York /
Aug.August 17, 2016 04:09 PM

Here’s a quick history lesson: When developer Arthur Benson bought pretty much all of Montauk back in 1879, he created a private club for himself and six of his friends. The resulting seven houses — dubbed the Seven Sisters — along with a central clubhouse now hold historical and architectural importance. (For those who appreciate some good architectural name dropping, they were designed by the esteemed firm McKim, Mead & White and “sited” by Central Park design master Frederick Law Olmsted.) Now one of those “sisters” has hit the market for $18.5 million. The home was originally owned by William Andrews, the founder of Grolier Club, a private bibliophile-lover Club On East 60th Street. The 3,800-square-foot home was rebuilt in the 1990s and is being marketed by Douglas Elliman. Meanwhile, in June, the East Hampton Star reported that hotelier Sean MacPherson — whose portfolio of hotels includes the trendy Crow’s Nest in Montauk — had a plan before the local zoning board to reconstruct the clubhouse, which burned down in the 1930s, as a private home. [Curbed] [EHS]Cathaleen Chen

Related Articles


Real estate bigwigs get into fistfight at Hamptons hotspot

Bravo reality star fights to keep Wainscott home from foreclosure, NYC developer brings a bookstore back to Sag Harbor & more Hamptons real estate news

An inside look at the Hamptons’ new hotspots this summer

Bridgehampton compound sells to Arbor Realty Trust CEO at a $14M discount

The Hamptons hotel hopscotch

Hamptons Cheat Sheet: Developer halts auction of 236 Suffolk properties, Chris Cuomo’s Southampton home finds buyer … & more

‘The Mooch’ buys in Manhasset, Christie Brinkley sells in Sag Harbor and more Hamptons & Long Island real estate news

Helmut Lang’s East Hampton compound could fetch $100M, Esprit founder unloads Sag Harbor home & more East End real estate news