Officials say federal Section 8 proposal won’t work in NYC

They argue the city doesn't have enough housing for the change

TRD New York /
Aug.August 17, 2016 06:10 PM

State and city officials are railing against a federal proposal to ramp up Section 8 rental subsidies in higher-income neighborhoods, saying it won’t work in apartment-strapped cities like New York.

In June, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development proposed increasing these rental subsidies in high-income neighborhoods and decreasing them in lower-income neighborhoods as a way to encourage subsidy recipients to move into wealthier areas and have access to better schools, jobs and opportunities. But officials, including Mayor Bill de Blasio and Sen. Chuck Schumer, argue that the shift wouldn’t accomplish this, Gothamist reported.

A spokesperson for the mayor told the website that there aren’t enough apartments in the city’s neighborhoods to accommodate the 119,000 voucher holders. Instead of moving to higher-income neighborhoods, under this proposed change, these tenants will either be forced to pay higher rents in their current homes or be forced out of the city, the spokesperson said.

In an open letter to HUD, Schumer and Rep. Nydia Velazquez wrote that the change would decrease voucher amounts for some 56,000 Section 8 tenants.

“These individuals and families will be expected to move to a higher-income neighborhood, be forced to re-negotiate with their landlord for a lower rent, or assume a significantly higher rent burden in order to stay in their home,” the letter states.

A HUD spokesperson noted that under the proposed change, New York would have the option to grandfather current Section 8 voucher holders. And there likely wouldn’t be new holders for some time: The vouchers have been closed to city applicants since 2009. [Gothamist]  — Kathryn Brenzel 

Related Article


Coalition revives effort to end “source of income” housing discrimination in New York

How one building transformed Hell’s Kitchen into wholesome “Clinton”

America spends a lot more on homeowner subsidy than on Section 8: report

Placeholder image

Starrett Corporation sells Hell’s Kitchen building for $110M

Camber Property and nonprofit buy Bronx housing complex for $71M

Bronx landlord Ved Parkash accused of discriminating against Section 8 tenants

Slate sues lawyers for allegedly giving bad advice on how to evict Section 8 tenants

NYC lawmakers ramping up fight against Section 8 proposal