Flophouse tenant barred from suing Bowery SRO owners

Landlords Meyer Muschel and Sam Chang had spent more than $200K defending frivolous suits

New York /
Nov.November 14, 2016 08:30 AM

A Manhattan judge has banned a litigious tenant of a storied Bowery SRO from suing his landlords.

Roland Davis was told that unless he gets a lawyer to represent him, he’s not allowed again to file suit against current or former owners of the famed Whitehouse Hotel at 338-340 Bowery – putting a stop to a string of nearly two dozen frivolous lawsuits.

“While public policy generally mandates free access to the courts, the court will not tolerate the use of the legal system as a tool of harassment,” Manhattan Judge Kelly O’Neill wrote in her decision, the New York Post reported.

Davis, who paid $8.32 per night for a windowless room, had sued the hotel 23 times in seven years, insisting that management make repairs to his small room and then refusing to let workers in, court papers show.

“I am both relieved and excited, not just for me, but for the fact the courts are willing to recognize that nobody should be permitted to use the system as a weapon,” said former owner Meyer Muschel, who had been sued.

Muschel and the building’s current owner Sam Chang TRData LogoTINY had spent more than $200,000 and appeared in court over 100 times defending the shaky claims.

O’Neil said Davis could return to court, but only if he had a lawyer or permission from a chief judge.

“You can’t get away with filing lawsuit after lawsuit after lawsuit against somebody even if you’re doing it pro se,” said Steven Sladkus, Muschel’s lawyer. “It’s very disruptive, time-consuming, and costly.” [NYP]Rich Bockmann


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
It may not be so easy to book a vacation this year: Rental listings are flying off the market, and prices are soaring. (iStock)
Bonkers season on tap for summer vacation rentals
Bonkers season on tap for summer vacation rentals
135-25 Northern Boulevard and 300 West 30th Street (Google Maps, Studio C Architects)
Self-storage company buys dev site from Home Depot
Self-storage company buys dev site from Home Depot
The Watson Hotel at 440 West 57th Street (Google Maps)
Developers already eyeing commercial-to-resi conversions
Developers already eyeing commercial-to-resi conversions
Photo illustration of Brookfield Property Partners’ Brian Kingston (Brookfield, iStock)
Struggling hotel company handing Brookfield the keys
Struggling hotel company handing Brookfield the keys
Rendering of H Hotel, slated for 58 West 39th Street (Peter Poon Architects)
Heavy hangover: Air rights purchased for massive cantilever
Heavy hangover: Air rights purchased for massive cantilever
Watson Hotel at 440 West 57th Street (Google Maps)
Manhattan hotel trades in biggest distressed lodging deal of pandemic
Manhattan hotel trades in biggest distressed lodging deal of pandemic
Lightstone Group CEO Mitchell Hochberg and Marriott International CEO Anthony Capuano with a rendering of The Moxy Williamsburg (Getty, Lightstone, iStock)
Marriott, Lightstone Group bet on hotel recovery
Marriott, Lightstone Group bet on hotel recovery
(iStock/Illustration by Kevin Rebong for The Real Deal)
Travel roars back — and summer rentals book up
Travel roars back — and summer rentals book up
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...