Retail faces a bleak future in NYC

Online competition cuts into earnings - and rents

New York /
Jan.January 23, 2017 03:55 PM

Manhattan’s retail rents fell in 2016, but some market observers predict the slide is only the beginning. The culprit: online retailers.

“There’s nowhere to go but down,” Cushman & Wakefield’s Steven Soutendijk told Crain’s. “Rents got too high too fast.”

One indicator of potential future rent decreases are availability rates, which remain precariously high in some sub-markets. On Fifth Avenue in the 40s, 31 percent of storefronts are available for rent in the fourth quarter, according to Cushman & Wakefield, but rents fell by a mere 1.1 percent compared to the fourth quarter of 2015. On Madison Avenue, where the availability stood at 23 percent, rents fell by 12 percent.

Several retailers blame the rise of online retail, which has cut into their earnings — and into their ability to pay high rents. Particularly hard-hit are clothing retailers and shops that compete directly with online giants like Amazon. Meanwhile, restaurants, bars and coffee shops still show strong demand for space, making up 41 percent of all leases signed last year, compared to 15 percent for apparel. Theme-park-like megastores like the Adidas shop on Fifth Avenue are also somewhat insulated from online competition, as they offer an experience online retailers can’t match.

“The model has to change,” said Alan Laytner, who owns Laytner’s Linen & Home on the Upper West Side. “Do you really need to sell a $20 pillow on Broadway?”

He said one reason his shop stayed afloat is that the landlord agreed to charge below-market rent.

Last month, ratings agency Fitch said it expects 9 percent of the retail sector’s debt to be in default by the end of 2017.

“A small number of players will do well,” said NYU marketing professor Scott Galloway. “Luxury brands will hold their own — you still can’t buy Hermès on Amazon. There will be some artisanal guys that will manage to hang on because they’re so exceptional. You’ll see Starbucks, Chipotle, more Warby Parker stores. And everyone else will get crushed.”

In July, The Real Deal reported that New York’s retail market could be entering a downturn.  [Crain’s]Konrad Putzier 


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Kohler Interiors' Rachel Kohler with  21-05 51st Avenue (Loopnet, Getty)
Tile retailer Ann Sacks inks 21K sf lease in Long Island City
Tile retailer Ann Sacks inks 21K sf lease in Long Island City
Vornado's Steve Roth with 1540 Broadway
Vornado writes down portfolio by $600M
Vornado writes down portfolio by $600M
(Photo Illustration by The Real Deal with Getty)
Big-box retail growth has Bed Bath & Beyond landlords thinking
Big-box retail growth has Bed Bath & Beyond landlords thinking
Chick-fil-A CEO Andrew Cathy and a rendering of Chik-fil-A 2205 Central Park Avenue in Yonkers  (Chik-fil-A/City of Yonkers)
Chick-fil-A hatches first Westchester location
Chick-fil-A hatches first Westchester location
Harry Macklowe with 1 Wall Street
Macklowe’s 1 Wall Street tops Manhattan’s largest retail leases of 2022
Macklowe’s 1 Wall Street tops Manhattan’s largest retail leases of 2022
(Photo Illustration by Steven Dilakian for The Real Deal with Getty)
Manhattan retail market rises again, but momentum wanes
Manhattan retail market rises again, but momentum wanes
Retail, Shopping Centers, Cushman & Wakefield
U.S. shopping center vacancy hits 15-year low
U.S. shopping center vacancy hits 15-year low
(Getty Images)
Bed Bath & Beyond weighs bankruptcy
Bed Bath & Beyond weighs bankruptcy
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...