Cuomo’s 421a program will cost city $8.4B over 10 years: IBO

The mayor's plan would cost $6B, agency says

TRD New York /
Mar.March 07, 2017 07:30 AM

Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s proposed replacement to 421a could cost the city $8.4 billion in property tax revenue over the next 10 years, according to a new report that perhaps further fuels the sniping between Albany and City Hall over the lapsed abatement.

The Independent Budget Office released a two-page report late Monday that estimates the governor’s proposal to revive 421a — called Affordable New York — will cost $2.3 billion more than the plan Mayor Bill de Blasio floated in 2015. The report also estimates that the governor’s program will cost the city $1.2 billion more than the legislation that was enacted in June 2015, an average of $120 million more per year and $1,440 more per apartment each year.

The short report is based on data provided by the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) and the mayor’s office, though it doesn’t break down how these numbers were arrived at. In January, HPD told Politico that the governor’s plan would cost $82 million more per year than the one the mayor proposed.

“There are clearly significant additional costs associated with the newly proposed 421a law,” Melissa Grace, a spokesperson for the mayor, said in an email. “Making sure we secure an appropriate degree of value for taxpayers is our obligation.”

A spokesperson for Cuomo’s office would only reiterate a statement put out earlier this year, saying “any expenses in exchange for making sure that all New Yorkers have a safe and decent place to call home are minimal, 26 years out, and worth it.”

Cuomo introduced Affordable New York in January, and since then, the governor and mayor’s administrations have taken turns swinging at each other. Just days after the program was announced, de Blasio voiced concern about unforeseen costs to the city and that more condominium projects might find their way into the legislation. Last month, the state’s outgoing housing commissioner Jamie Rubin blamed de Blasio for the program’s extra costs. He said the mayor’s proposal for the abatement served as the foundation for the June 2015 legislation, and was “much more expensive,” but will also create “much more affordable housing.” He said the only difference with the governor’s Affordable New York program was the “change that was necessary to restart the program.”

But the IBO report points to just those changes as largely the cause for the extra costs. The changes include construction wage requirements for projects south of 96th Street in Manhattan and along the waterfronts in Brooklyn and Queens. These projects, as well as certain large developments that opt to pay the wages, are eligible for an extended 35-year abatement. The report projects that the city will pay $68,500 per apartment in Manhattan’s wage zone, compared with $59,300 outside it. In Queens, the city would pay $42,000 per apartment in the wage zone compared to $21,600. In Brooklyn, the city would pay $39,800 to compared to $34,400.

Still, the IBO report doesn’t account for the argument put forward by many of New York City’s leading developers: That without the tax abatement, rental development just isn’t feasible. The report seems to assume that the revenue-producing projects would be created with or without a 421a program in place.

Geoffrey Propheter, a property tax analyst for the IBO who prepared the report, acknowledged that while the lost tax revenue could be an overestimation, it’s likely a small one. He said the projects that “live or die by 421a” — those in lower-income areas — tend to expend less property taxes anyway. So, even if those properties weren’t included in the report, the numbers would likely be roughly the same.

“It’s kind of like throwing a lawn chair off of the Titanic,” he said.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
(Image by Wolfgang & Hite via Dezeen)

Hudson Yards megadevelopment inspires a new line of sex toys

Hudson Yards megadevelopment inspires a new line of sex toys
Cammeby's International Group founder Rubin Schron and, from top: 194-05 67th Avenue, 189-15 73rd Avenue and 64-05 186th Lane (Credit: Google Maps)

Ruby Schron lands $500M refi for sprawling Queens apartment portfolio

Ruby Schron lands $500M refi for sprawling Queens apartment portfolio
Wendy Silverstein (Credit: Getty Images)

Wendy Silverstein, co-head of WeWork’s real-estate fund, is out

Wendy Silverstein, co-head of WeWork’s real-estate fund, is out
Number 22 Bishopsgate

Trophy office towers could become a thing of the past in London

Trophy office towers could become a thing of the past in London
Rana Creek Ranch (Credit: Hall & Hall)

Lesser-known Apple co-founder re-lists 14,000-acre California ranch

Lesser-known Apple co-founder re-lists 14,000-acre California ranch
A mass timber project in Cleveland is now under construction and could be the nation’s tallest when completed. Harbor Bay Real Estate Advisors’ Intro development will rise nine stories with 298 residential units (Credit: Harbor Bay Real Estate Advisors)

Mass timber project in Cleveland could be nation’s tallest

Mass timber project in Cleveland could be nation’s tallest
Realty Board on Labor Relations president Howard Rothschild and 32BJ SEIU President Kyle Bragg (Credit: Facebook, Linkedin)

Negotiating in a pandemic: 32BJ, landlords reach reopening deal

Negotiating in a pandemic: 32BJ, landlords reach reopening deal
Joy Construction’s Eli Weiss (left), Maddd Equities’ Jorge Madruga (top), and Drew Katz (right) with 20 Bruckner Boulevard in the Bronx (Getty; Google Maps)

“Dream” comes true for long-vacant Bronx ice house

“Dream” comes true for long-vacant Bronx ice house
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...