Son vs. father: Richard Ohebshalom sues Fred over 111 Washington deal

Investor alleges Fred wants to sell the site to a Chinese buyer for $148M

TRD New York /
Mar.March 17, 2017 01:56 PM

The saga of 111 Washington Street now includes a bitter lawsuit between father and son.

For years, plans to develop the large Financial District site started and stopped. Now, Richard Ohebshalom is suing his father, Fred, for trying to push through the sale of the property for far less Richard thinks it’s worth.

In a suit filed March 15, Richard said his father is using the site as a pawn in an ongoing dispute between them. In particular, he alleges that Fred — founder of Empire Management — wants to sell 111 Washington for the “woefully deficient” price of $148 million “in a bad faith effort to extract concessions from Richard.”

The Ohebshaloms are partners in several properties, including 111 Washington, which Richard’s Pink Stone Capital bought for $57.5 million in 2011. Pink Stone picked up the defaulted note from New York Community Bank, and then bought up another 200,000 square feet of air rights to support a 362,000-square-foot residential or mixed-use development. Under an operating agreement for the property, Fred can’t sell the site without his son’s consent, the complaint states. Further, a 2013 agreement caps Fred’s share of any proceeds if the building is sold for more than $120 million.

In January, Fred agreed not to sell the property while they continued to hammer out a settlement, according to court documents. But instead, the complaint alleges, he began to “secretly negotiate a wholly-inadequate sale” of the property. Last week, Fred’s attorneys advised Richard that his father intended to sell the property to a “Chinese buyer” for $148 million.

In the complaint, Richard argues that not only does Fred lack the authority to sell, but also that the property is worth at least $180 million, as was detailed in the 2013 agreement. Still, Fred listed the property for $170 million and previously negotiated with a buyer who offered $170 million, the complaint said.

“Fred’s pursuit of the proposed sale is motivated solely by his desire to increase leverage over Richard in connection with settlement negotiations on unrelated family and business matter,” the complaint states.

Representatives for Fred declined to comment, while representatives for Richard did not respond to requests for comment. According to the complaint, the Ohebshaloms have sparred over how to manage several of their properties and in the past year, as part of settlement talks, they discussed the possibility of exchanging some co-owned properties, including 111 Washington.

Plans for 111 Washington have changed several times over the years.

Shortly after buying the site, which is two blocks south of the World Trade Center, Pink Stone said it would develop a 54-story rental tower with roughly 500 units.

But in March 2014, Pink Stone put the site on the market for $260 million, only to pull it off  the market, file building plans for the tower and then re-list the development site a year later. That time, listing broker Bob Knakal TRData LogoTINY said he expected it would fetch north of $170 million.


Related Articles

arrow_forward_ios
Vishaan Chakrabarti of Practice for Architecture and Urbanism and Hiten Samtani of The Real Deal (Getty)

Vishaan Chakrabarti on a Manhattan real estate market without private cars

Vishaan Chakrabarti on a Manhattan real estate market without private cars
Vishaan Chakrabarti of Practice for Architecture and Urbanism and Hiten Samtani of The Real Deal (Getty)

The REInterview: What if Manhattan had four Central Parks’ worth of land to play with?

The REInterview: What if Manhattan had four Central Parks’ worth of land to play with?
Social Construct CEO Ben Huh, The Real Deal's Hiten Samtani and Social Construct cofounder Michael Yarne

The REInterview: Social Construct’s founders on making multifamily construction an assembly line

The REInterview: Social Construct’s founders on making multifamily construction an assembly line
2870 Ocean Avenue in Sheepshead Bay (Google Maps)

Chetrit firm to acquire Sheepshead Bay development site

Chetrit firm to acquire Sheepshead Bay development site
Alexandria Real Estate Equities founder Joel Marcus and Alexandria Center for Life Sciences (Getty, Google Maps)

Life-sciences sector proves safe haven for landlords

Life-sciences sector proves safe haven for landlords
123 West 23rd Street and Adam Neumann (Google Maps; Getty Images)

Adam Neumann, Jeff Dagowitz get $75M refi for Chelsea dev site

Adam Neumann, Jeff Dagowitz get $75M refi for Chelsea dev site
22-15 31st Street (Google Maps)

Supermarket signals demise as Target eyes Astoria

Supermarket signals demise as Target eyes Astoria
270 Park Avenue (Google Maps; iStock)

City planning through a pandemic

City planning through a pandemic
arrow_forward_ios

The Deal's newsletters give you the latest scoops, fresh headlines, marketing data, and things to know within the industry.

Loading...