Do landlords make money under rent stabilization? Depends whom you ask

A recent study shows a 10.8% increase in NOI, but some multifamily landlords contest the data

TRD New York /
Apr.April 03, 2017 09:00 AM

(Credit: New York City Rent Guidelines Board, Click to enlarge)

If you believe the Rent Guidelines Board, it’s a great time to be a landlord of rent-stabilized apartments. The RBG’s latest report, released Thursday, said that net operating income in buildings with stabilized apartments increased nearly 11 percent from 2014 to 2015, the highest recorded increase since 1997 to 1998.

But the NOI figures — which measures the difference between a building’s income and expenses, submitted annually by most landlords to the Department of Finance — and the study’s methodology have been criticized by landlords, who say they don’t account for major expenses.

“In the past and in the way the reports are written, NOI is used as a proxy for profit,” said Patrick Siconolfi, executive director of the Community Housing Improvement Program, in his testimony on behalf of owners last April. “It’s not, and this is a very serious misunderstanding,” he added. “It’s not the cost of delivering a unit of housing to the people of this city.”

Siconolfi and other multifamily landlords point out that because the NOI figures do not take into account a building’s debt service or the expenses of capital investments, they do not accurately represent the cost of owning buildings with rent-stabilized units.

The RGB, whose members are appointed by Mayor Bill de Blasio, uses the NOI calculation, among other data points, to set allowed rent increases for one- and two-year leases for roughly half of the city’s rental apartments. The annual allowance is one of the main ways landlords can increase rents for rent-stabilized tenants.

Joseph Strasburg, president of the landlord group Rent Stabilization Association, expressed his concern with the RGB’s report. “The fix is in,” he said in a statement Thursday. “The RGB’s numbers defy logic.”

Others say the report produced by the RGB is pretty fair. Barring further transparency from building owners, the report “is about as precise a measure of the relative increase in the income stream as you can possibly get,” according to Tim Collins, partner at Collins, Dobkin & Miller and the former executive director of the RGB.

Collins says the report demonstrates that owning rent-stabilized apartments has been profitable for landlords, though many landlords contest that claim. Since 1990, the earliest year data is available, NOI has increased 57.7 percent, with Brooklyn seeing the largest increase at 97 percent, the report notes.

At the same time, the number of “distressed” properties with stabilized units – buildings where expenses exceeded income – reached its lowest point since 1990 at 5.4 percent, according to the RGB.

“The balance that is being stricken here is decisively in favor of owners and has caused great harm to tenants,” Collins said.

In the last two years, the RGB has frozen rents on stabilized one-year leases, much to the ire of the RSA, which sued to reverse last year’s ruling. Earlier this week, a judge upheld the rent freeze.

Related Article

Blackstone CEO Steven Schwartzman and Stuyvesant Town (Credit: Getty Images)

After authorities vowed review of Stuy Town deal, Blackstone changes course on vacancies

Real Capital Analytics data showed that New York’s multifamily market had a very slow July. (Credit: iStock)

New NYC rent law “beginning to shut down investment”

Some landlords say they plan to close the door to vacant apartments and wait for the laws to change (Credit: iStock)

Creative ways NYC landlords are getting around the new rent rules

The massive meeting held in a suburban casino outside of Utica came at a time when the real estate industry is asking itself some tough questions. (Credit: iStock)

Meet the 400 landlords that are taking rent laws into their own hands

State Senator Julia Salazar (Credit: Getty Images and iStock)

Sen. Julia Salazar proposes legislation to crack down on buyouts

From left: New York Communities for Change director Jonathan Westin, Neighborhood First Fund program director Joan Byron, and Ford Foundation president Darren Walker (Credit: NYC Communities, LinkedIn, and Ford Foundation)

The money behind the New York tenant movement

Blackstone CEO Stephen Schwarzman and Stuyvesant Town (Credit: Getty Images)

Authorities will conduct review of Stuy Town deal in light of Blackstone’s vacancy strategy

Israeli financier Jonathan Leitersdorf had big plans for a prime High Line site -- but taxi drivers, tenant-harassing strip club owners, and a retired FBI agent have turned the project into an absolute circus.

How an FBI agent, strip club owners and cab drivers decimated this High Line luxury project